Chapter V.
He proceeds against his opponent with the choicest arguments, and shows that we ought
to hold fast to the religion which we have received from our fathers.
If you were an assertor of the Arian or Sabellian heresy, and did not use your own creed,
I would still confute you by the authority of the holy Scriptures; I would confute you by the
words of the law itself; I would refute you by the truth of the Creed which has been approved
throughout the whole world. I would say that, even if you were void of sense and understand-
ing, yet still you ought at least to follow universal consent: and not to make more of the
perverse view of a few wicked men than of the faith of all the Churches: which as it was es-
tablished by Christ, and handed down by the apostles ought to be regarded as nothing but
the voice of the authority of God, which is certainly in possession of the voice and mind of
God. And what then if I were to deal with you in this way? What would you say? What
would you answer? Would it not, I adjure you, be this: viz., that you had not been trained
up and taught in this way: that something different had been delivered to you by your parents,
and masters, and teachers. That you did not hear this in the meeting place of your father’s
teaching, nor in the Church of your Baptism: finally that the text and words of the Creed
delivered and taught to you contained something different. That in it you were baptized
and regenerated. You would say that you would hold fast this which you had received, and
that you would live in that Creed in which you learnt that you were regenerated. When you
said this, would you not, I pray, fancy that you were using a very strong shield even against
the truth? And indeed it would be no unreasonable defence, even in a bad business, and one
which would give no bad excuse for error, if it did not unite obstinacy with error. For if you
held this, which you had received from your childhood, we should try to amend and correct
your present error, rather than be severe in punishing your past fault: Whereas now, as you
were born in a Catholic city, instructed in the Catholic faith, and regenerated with Catholic
Baptism, how can I deal with you as with an Arian or Sabellian? Would that you were one!
I should grieve less had you been brought up in what was wrong, instead of having fallen
away from what was right: had you never received the faith, instead of having lost it: had
you been an old heretic instead of a fresh apostate, for you would have brought less scandal
and harm on the whole Church; finally it would have been a less bitter sorrow, and less in-
jurious example had you been able to try the Church as a layman rather than a priest.
Therefore, as I said above, if you had been a follower and assertor of Sabellianism or
Arianism or any heresy you please, you might shelter yourself under the example of your
parents, the teaching of your instructors, the company of those about you, the faith of your
594
creed. I ask, O you heretic, nothing unfair, and nothing hard. As you have been brought up
in the Catholic faith, do that which you would do for a wrong belief. Hold fast to the
teaching of your parents. Hold fast the faith of the Church: hold fast the truth of the Creed:
hold fast the salvation of baptism. What sort of a wonder—what sort of a monster are you?
Chapter V. He proceeds against his opponent with the choicest arguments, and shows that we ought to hold fast to the religion which we have received from our fathers.
1493
Chapter V. He proceeds against his opponent with the choicest arguments,…