8. We have therefore—as I suppose—shown sufficiently, that to the immortal gods
temples have been either reared in vain, or built in consequence of insulting opinions held
to their dishonour and to the belittling4617 of the power believed to be in their hands. We
have next to say something about statues and images, which you form with much skill, and
tend with religious care,—wherein if there is any credibility, we can by no amount of con-
sideration settle in our own minds whether you do this in earnest and with a serious purpose,
or amuse yourselves in childish dreams by mocking at these very things.4618 For if you are
assured that the gods exist whom you suppose, and that they live in the highest regions of
heaven, what cause, what reason, is there that those images should be fashioned by you,
when you have true beings to whom you may pour forth prayers, and from whom you may
ask help in trying circumstances? But if, on the contrary, you do not believe, or, to speak
with moderation, are in doubt, in this case, also, what reason is there, pray, to fashion and
set up images of doubtful beings, and to form4619 with vain imitation what you do not believe
to exist? Do you perchance say, that under these images of deities there is displayed to you
their presence, as it were, and that, because it has not been given you to see the gods, they
are worshipped in this fashion,4620 and the duties owed to them paid? He who says and asserts
this, does not believe that the gods exist; and he is proved not to put faith in his own religion,
to whom it is necessary to see what he may hold, lest that which being obscure is not seen,
may happen to be vain.
4617 [“Belittle.” This word here is noteworthy. President Jefferson is said to have coined it, and I have never
before seen it in a transatlantic book.]
4618 i.e., “which you pretend to worship.”
4619 So the edd., reading formar-e, except Hild. and Oehler, who retain the ms. reading i—“that images be
formed.”
4620 The ms. and both Roman edd. read corruptly insolidi, corrected ita or sic coli, as above, in all except the
last two edd.
Chapter VIII.
1234
Chapter VIII.