his familiarity with revivals of religion, his freedom from enthusiasm, and his utter aversion
to extravagance and disorder, was admirably qualified to execute it in the happiest manner:
and, from the time of its first publication, it has been, to a very wide extent, the common
text-book of evangelical divines, on the subject of which it treats. If the reader will examine
the various accounts of revivals of religion, he will find that no one of them, anterior to this,
furnishes an explanation of the subject, in accordance with the acknowledged principles of
mental philosophy.
In 1743, about one hundred and sixty ministers published their attestations to this work,
as in their own view a genuine work of the Spirit of God, and as having been extraordinary
and remarkable; on account of the numbers who discovered a deep anxiety for their salvation;
on account of its rapid progress from place to place; and on account of the power with which
it was carried on. Yet, while they bear witness to the great numbers who appeared to have
become real Christians, to the extensive reformation of morals which it occasioned, and to
a greater prevalence of religion than they had before witnessed; many of them also regret
the extravagances and irregularities, which in some places had been permitted to accompany
it. Among these, they particularly point out—a disposition to make secret impulses on the
mind a rule of duty laymen invading the ministerial office, and under a pretence of exhorting,
setting up preaching—ministers invading each other’s provinces—indiscreet young men
rushing into particular places, and preaching on all occasions—unscriptural separations of
churches, and of ministers from their churches—a rash judging of the religious state of
others—and a controversial, uncharitable, and censorious spirit.
lxxi
There can be no doubt, that both parts of this statement are true. Although this most
extensive work of grace opened on New England, in 1740 and 1741, in a manner eminently
auspicious; yet in the two following years, it assumed, in various places, a somewhat different
aspect, and was unhappily marked with irregularity and disorder. This was doubtless owing,
in some degree, to the fact, that many ministers of wisdom and sound discretion, not advert-
ing sufficiently to the extent and importance of the apostolic exhortation, “Let all things be
done decently and in order,” either encouraged, or did not effectually suppress, outcries,
falling down and swooning, in the time of public and social worship, the speaking and
praying of women in the church and in mixed assemblies, the meeting of children by
themselves for religious worship, and singing and praying aloud in the streets; but far more
to the unrestrained zeal of a considerable number of misguided men—some of them
preachers of the gospel, and others lay exhorters—who, intending to take Mr. Whitefield
as their model, travelled from place to place, preaching and exhorting wherever they could
collect an audience; pronounced definitively and unhesitatingly with respect to the piety of
individuals, both ministers and private Christians; and whenever they judged a minister, or
a majority of his church, destitute of piety—which they usually did, not on account of their
false principles or their irreligious life, but for their want of an ardour and zeal equal to their
138
CHAPTER XII. Extent of the revival of 1740-1742. Auspicious opening. Opposed…