Donatism; there is the debate before chosen hearers, all the statements to be written out for
use; or there is the private discussion through mutual discourse, to be read to one another
and corrected, and so given to the people; or the single correspondence with a view to public
lections, or any possible way that the aged bishop himself might prefer. He urges that the
dead bury their dead, and the past history be left out of the debate; the present with its
burning dissensions affords sufficient topics. As the people seek the bishop to arbitrate in
their private litigations, let these worthies cultivate peace in this broader field; to this end
he invites to prayer and conference. (Ep. xxxiii.).
Apparently the letter led to nothing practical. A new turn was given to matters. A son
had beaten his mother, and threatened her life; to avoid Catholic discipline, he joined the
Donatists and was rebaptized by them: as Augustin says, he wounded also his spiritual
mother by contemning her sacrament. Public registration of the facts were made by Augustin,
376
all the more because the reported instructions, given by bishop Proculeianus to his presbyter
Victor concerning the affair, had already been denied. The case presented an opportunity
for getting at some rule for the recognition of one another’s discipline. Accordingly Augustin
addresses himself to Eusebius, a judicious Donatist of higher rank. He professes that his
aim is peace; he emphasizes with impatient vehemence his opposition to coercive measures
in matters of conscience: neque me id agere ut ad communionem catholicam quisquam
cogatur invitus. He asks Eusebius to find out whether Proculeianus had given the order to
his presbyter as recorded; whether the bishop would consent to a collation between them-
selves and ten selected men on each side, agreeably to the original suggestion so that the
whole question might be discussed from the Scriptural grounds, not the historical. Some
proposals for a meeting either at the Donatist region of Constantina, or at their projected
council at Milevis, he could not accept, because both lay outside of his diocese. If Proculei-
anus objected to the dialectic and rhetorical skill of his counter bishop, the latter would
propose Samsucius, bishop of Turris, an earnest but uncultivated man, as a substitute to
lead the Catholic side. (Ep. xxxiv.).
Eusebius declined to interfere on the ground that he could not be a judge, so Augustin
replies (Ep. xxxv.) that he had only asked him to make some inquiries, because the bishop
refused to have any direct communication. The need for some adjustment concerning dis-
cipline had become very pressing; a Catholic subdeacon and some nuns under rebuke had
been received into full standing by the Donatists, yet their subsequent career had been even
more scandalous. Augustin claimed that the Catholics always respected the penal enactments
of their opponents. To show his own hostility to compulsory conversions, he cites the case
of a daughter, who against the paternal will had joined the Donatists, and had professed
among them; when the father was about to use violence for her recall, he was dissuaded by
Augustin, and when a presbyter of Proculeianus had shouted abusive epithets at him, al-
652
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.