48. But, says some one, you in vain claim so much for Christ, when we now know, and
have in past times known, of other gods both giving remedies to many who were sick, and
healing the diseases and the infirmities of many men. I do not inquire, I do not demand,
what god did so, or at what time; whom he relieved, or what shattered frame he restored to
sound health: this only I long to hear, whether, without the addition of any substance—that
is, of any medical application—he ordered diseases to fly away from men at a touch;
whether he commanded and compelled the cause of ill health to be eradicated, and the
bodies of the weak to return to their natural strength. For it is known that Christ, either by
applying His hand to the parts affected, or by the command of His voice only, opened the
ears of the deaf, drove away blindness from the eyes, gave speech to the dumb, loosened the
rigidity of the joints, gave the power of walking to the shrivelled,—was wont to heal by a
word and by an order, leprosies, agues, dropsies, and all other kinds of ailments, which some
fell power3334 has willed that the bodies of men should endure. What act like these have all
these gods done, by whom you allege that help has been brought to the sick and the imper-
illed? for if they have at any time ordered, as is reported, either that medicine or a special
diet be given to some,3335 or that a draught be drunk off, or that the juices of plants and of
blades be placed3336 on that which causes uneasiness or have ordered that persons should
walk, remain at rest, or abstain from something hurtful,—and that this is no great matter,
and deserves no great admiration, is evident, if you will attentively examine it—a similar
mode of treatment is followed by physicians also, a creature earth-born and not relying on
true science, but founding on a system of conjecture, and wavering in estimating probabil-
ities. Now there is no special merit in removing by remedies those ailments which affect
men: the healing qualities belong to the drugs—not virtues inherent in him who applies
them; and though it is praiseworthy to know by what medicine or by what method it may
be suitable for persons to be treated, there is room for this credit being assigned to man, but
not to the deity. For it is, at least, no discredit that he3337 should have improved the health
of man by things taken from without: it is a disgrace to a god that he is not able to effect it
of himself, but that he gives soundness and safety only by the aid of external objects.
3334 See book ii. chap. 36, infra.
3335 The gods in whose temples the sick lay ordered remedies through the priests.
3336 So all edd. except LB., which reads with the ms. superponere—“that (one) place the juices,” etc.
3337 That is, the physician.
Chapter XLVIII.
968
Chapter XLVIII.