youthful Oxonians whom our modern Tertullian carried with him into the papal schism,
could never have been made dupes but for the persistent empiricism of orthodox writers
who practically adopt in words what they refute in argument, calling all bishops of Rome
“Popes,” and even including St. Peter’s blessed name in this fallacious designation.1111 In
this series I adhere to the logic of facts, calling (1) all the bishops of Rome from Linus to
Sylvester simply bishops; and (2) all their successors to Nicholas I. “patriarchs” under the
Nicene Constitutions, which they professed to honour, though, after Gregory the Great, they
were ever vying with Constantinople to make themselves greater. (3) Nicholas, who trampled
on the Nicene Constitutions, and made the false decretals the canon law of the Western
churches, was therefore the first “Pope” who answers to the Tridentine definitions. Even
these, however, were never able to make dogmatic1112 the claim of “supremacy,” which was
first done by Pius IX. in our days. A canonical Primacy is one thing: a self-asserted Supremacy
is quite another, as the French doctors have abundantly demonstrated.
IV.
(Contemporaneous heresy, p. 125.)
Here begins that “duplicating of our knowledge” of primitive Rome of which Bunsen
speaks so justly. A thorough mastery of this book will prepare us to understand the great
Cyprian in all his relations with the Roman Province, and not less to comprehend the affairs
of Novatian.
Bunsen, with all respect, does not comprehend the primitive system, and reads it back-
ward, from the modern system, which travesties antiquity even in its apparent conformities.
These conformities are only the borrowing of old names for new contrivances. Thus, he
reads the cardinals of the eleventh century into the simple presbytery of comprovincial
bishops of the third century,1113 just as he elsewhere lugs in the Ave Maria of modern Italy
to expound the Evening Hymn to the Trinity.1114 In a professed Romanist, like De Maistre,
this would be resented as jugglery. But let us come to facts. Bunsen’s preliminary remarks1115
are excellent. But when he comes to note an “exceptional system” in the Roman “presbytery,”
1111 How St. Peter would regard it, see 1 Pet. v. 1–3. I am sorry to find Dr. Schaff, in his useful compilation,
History of the Christian Church, vol. ii. p 166, dropping into the old ruts of fable, after sufficiently proving just
before, what I have maintained. He speaks of “the insignificance of the first Popes,”—meaning the early Bishops
of Rome, men who minded their own business, but could not have been “insignificant” had they even imagined
themselves “Popes.”
1112 See Bossuet, passim, and all the Gallican doctors down to our own times. In England the “supremacy”
was never acknowledged, nor in France, until now.
1113 See his Hippol., vol. i. pp. 209, 311.
1114 See vol. ii. p. 298, this series.
1115 p. 207.
396
Elucidations.