SECTION 9
James 4:11-12
EVIL
James 4:11
11 Speak not one against another, brethren.---James reverts to a subject, the improper use of the tongue, which has claimed his attention again and again in the Epistle. To no other matter does he devote so much time and space. We must therefore conclude that those to whom he wrote were particularly prone to this sin and therefore needed special instruction and warnings touching the matter. If those of that day were prone to sin in this manner, they evidence the fact that they were much like us today; there is certainly no more common sin among "saints" and sinners today; and no more obvious and clear indication of the depravity of man than the disposition to engage in slander. calumny and detraction. It is not unlikely that the writer intended for this section to be construed in close connection with the preceding one; the haughty and proud disposition there di:;cussed often leads those who allege their own superiority to speak disparagingly of those whom they regard as beneath them. Moreover, the writer had discussed, in detail, in the verses preceding. the sins which result from an absence of love for God ; here, he gives attention to those sins which follow from a lack of love for the brethren.
It is, of course, the want of Joy for each other that prompts us to express adverse judgments regarding others. We are all especially prone to make excuses for those whom we appreciate and love; to excuse, justify and forgive them for their weaknesses : and to criticise, condemn and flay those whom we dislike. Such a disposition is sinful, and vigorously condemned by James in this section. One may speak evil of another by unjustly criticising his actions, words, life; by taking up evil reports originated by others against a brother and giving them further circulation. All such censorious activity is sinful and wrong.
"Speak not one against another," (me katalaleite allelon), is, literally, "Stop speaking against each other!'' The imperative with the negative me (not), is significant, and condemns the habit or practice of thus engaging. This construction forbids not only the act, but also the will so to do. This would include and forbid not only the expression of harsh words regarding others but also the entertainment of such thoughts concerning them. Whether the rendering here should be "against each other," or "about one another", the meaning is, in this instance, mnch the same; condcnmed is censorious comment regarding others. That these to whom James wrote were engaging actively in that which he forbids is evident from the use of the present imperative with the negative; hence, "Stop speaking against each other." Those thus engaged are styled brethren. Members of the church are thus by no means immune from this sin.
It would be well for all of us to remember that if there is such a thing as evil-speaking, there is also evil-hearing, a necessary accompaniment of evil-speaking. Indeed, were it not for those who listen to calumnies regarding others, there would be no one to speak such. Because we cujoy hearing bad things about each other is a basic reason why slanderers enjoy telling bad things about others. We are disposed, as conversationalists, to relate matters which please our hearers; and, because many listeners delight in slander, we are tempted to satisfy this desire, and thus to tell that which we know pleases them. To "run another down" was a common sin in the ancient world, and is not less practiced today. The verb implies not only evil-speaking, but such speaking as is done in the absence of another, i.e., "behind his back." Those who indulge in such conversation greatly displease the Father, and effectively close the door of grace against them.
David inquired, "Jehovah, who shall sojourn in thy tabernacle? Who shall dwell in thy holy hill ?" The Psalmist answered his own questions in these words: "He that walketh uprightly, and worketh righteousness, and speaketh truth in his heart; he that slandereth with his tongue, nor doeth evil to his friend, nor taketh up a reproach against his neighbor.... " (Psalms 15:1-3.)
He that speaketh against a brother, or judgeth his brother, speaketh against the law, and judgeth the law:---To judge a brother, in the sense here intended, is to form unfavorable opinions regarding him without being able or willing to know the real character of the act condemned, or the motives which Jed to it:' commission. It is to impute unworthy motives to others; to put the worst possible interpretation on their words and actions. One who thus does not only violates the injunction which forbid;: evil speaking against a brother, such a one also speaks against the law, and judges the law. This one does, by ignoring that precept of the law which bids us to love one another, and by acting in a fashion contrary to it. By refusing to do what the law commands, --to love one's neighbor as oneself- such a person passes judgment upon the law by declaring that it is not good nor worthy of being obeyed. Such a practice is, in effect, to say that the law of love is a bad one, or at best clefective; and may. therefore, be disregarded.
This attitude is highhanded and presumptious; it is a wicked attempt to pass judgment upon the acts of God himself! To exercise the office of a censor is to play the part of a judge; and this one does who abandons the law of love and speaks evil of his brethren. The proper province of Christians is to be "doers of the law," not judges of it; and to be guilty of that which James here condemns--cataloging the faults of others is to violate the very law for which such affect great respect.
but if thou judgest the law, thou art not a doer of the law, but a judge.---The "judging," which is condemned here is censorious judgment, a type of ill-natured criticism resulting from hasty and imperfect conceptions, and based upon partial or incorrect information. There is, in the effort, an allegation of superiority, the implication that the one doing it is better, more intelligent, possessed of greater wisdom than others. The critic thus becomes a judge, not exercising his judgment in a specific realm, and with reference to detailed charges established by testimony from credible and competent witnesses, but from surmise, suspicion, and malice. This is a palpable and strict violation of the law of love. (Luke 19:18.) It is the responsibility of us all to obey the law of God, and not violate it, or attempt to pass judgment as to its worth or validity. The law contemplated here is doubtless the law of Christ; but the principle is applicable to any law under which we live, and to which we are answerable. if it is not in violation of Scripture. It is absurd for one to affect great respect for law, and to condemn unjustly one's brother when the dispositiun is itself a violation of the law.
The tense of the verbs here used indicates. not an occasional lapse into this sin. but a constant and habitual addiction thereto. Such appears to have been characteristic of those to whom James wrote ; and is not surprising. because those who speak c\'il of others occasionally, will eventually fall into the harmful habit of doing it continuously. We thus learn that it is impossible to be in a right relationship with God, without sustaining the proper relation with our brethren. "If a man say. I love God. and hateth his brother, he is a liar: for he that loveth not his brother whom he hath seen, cannot love God whom he hath not seen." ( l John 4:20.) "He that loveth his brother abideth in the light, and there is no occasion of stumbling in him. But he that hatcth his brother is in the darkness, ancl knoweth not whither he gocth, because the darkness hath blinded his eyes." ( l John 2:10-11.)
{"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation or note-count claim","html_tags":{"p":13},"id":"sqlite3:5fb87c9182736a329b6c330747587f24405d46b6f2d3aad595a43ba53cae0300:commentaries:88","native_body_column":"text","native_module_context_literals":{"description":"A Commentary on the New Testament Epistles","language":"en"},"native_module_metadata_ref":{"$context_sha256":"ab52a70f08c2bf542a06a1ad0b8e172c2a748270bbf0ef42ed42537c4eccdce8"},"native_reference":{"book_number":660,"chapter_number_from":4,"chapter_number_to":4,"verse_number_from":11,"verse_number_to":11},"native_rowid":88,"native_table":"commentaries","projection":"HTML character data with explicit block newlines; no text-node deletion or whitespace folding; original HTML retained","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-verse-keyed-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"sermonindex","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"e1463c6982ad109a43a24bc705d30aaaa2e1563ef4282de8b7d8c3b4c06216ab"},"source_html_sha256":"e1463c6982ad109a43a24bc705d30aaaa2e1563ef4282de8b7d8c3b4c06216ab","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"82aff79f4ab45b9a631a8a82bad3bee9a43fc27bc0a39fc77336e8b7cafd19cc"},"source_origin_path":"SI-WOODS.commentaries.SQLite3","source_sha256":"5fb87c9182736a329b6c330747587f24405d46b6f2d3aad595a43ba53cae0300"}