Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(Meletian schism, p. 259.)
The date of the Meletian schism is very much in need of elucidation. I follow Neale,
however, as follows: Athanasius places its origin a.d. 306 (according to Tillemont and Bar-
onius) or a.d. 301; the latter more probable, as demonstrated by the Benedictine editors.
But the dates are, perhaps, the least of the difficulties which encumber the whole matter.
Somewhat distrustfully I have, after several efforts to construct an original elucidation, ad-
opted the theory of Neale, as a diligent and conscientious inquirer whose Oriental studies
284
qualify him to utter almost a decisive voice, albeit he never forgets his Occidentalism, and
hence fails to speak with absolute fidelity to the spirit of Catholic antiquity.
We know something of Lycopolis from the blessed Alexander; it seems to have been a
sort of centre to the bishoprics of the Thebais. It was just the sort of centre, in a region suf-
ficient for a separate patriarchate, to suggest to an ambitious and unscrupulous prelate an
effort at independency. Meletius, who succeeded the good Alexander, was just the man to
set up for himself; a man not unlikely to be stimulated by the bad example of Paul of Sam-
osata, and by the ingenuity that triumphed over the first council that called Paul to account.
Bearing all this in mind, we may accept Neale’s conviction that Meletius had long been a
scandal to the churches, and in the time of persecution had lapsed, and sacrificed to idols.
Peter summoned him to a council, by which he was convicted and degraded; whereupon
he not only refused to submit, but arrogated to himself the cathedra of Alexandria, and
began to ordain other bishops, and, in short, to reorganize its jurisdiction.2390 Owing, I
think probable, to the exceptional and overgrown extent of this enormous “patriarchate,”
as it was called a little later, the schism gained a considerable following. The distance of
Lycopolis from Lower Egypt must have favoured the attempt, and Peter’s recent accession
made it easy for Meletius to circulate evil stories against him. The schism, as usual, soon
developed into heresy, which even the Nicene Synod failed to extinguish. Arius had joined
the first outbreak, but conformed for a time, and was ordained a deacon by Achillas. His
troublesome spirit, however, soon showed itself again after his ordination to the priesthood;
and the remnant of the Meletians made common cause with him after his condemnation
at Nicæa. Of Peter’s legitimate exercise of authority, and of the impurity and wickedness of
Meletius before his invasion of Alexandria, there is no reason to doubt; but for the details,
recourse must be had to Neale.2391 The famous Sixth Canon of Nice finds its explanation
in this rebellion; but, incidentally, it defines the position of other great centres, which now
2390 He reported to the Nicene Council that he had ordained twenty-eight bishops and eight priests or deacons.
2391 Patriarchate of Alexandria, vol. i. pp. 91, 146.
Elucidations.
651
Elucidations.