174
Book VII.
The genealogical question is again taken up and argued on both sides.
1. Faustus said: You ask why I do not believe in the genealogy of Jesus. There are many
reasons; but the principal is, that He never declares with His own lips that He had an earthly
father or descent, but on the contrary, that he is not of this world, that He came forth from
God the Father, that He descended from heaven, that He has no mother or brethren except
those who do the will of His Father in heaven. Besides, the framers of these genealogies do
not seem to have known Jesus before His birth or soon after it, so as to have the credibility
of eye-witnesses of what they narrate. They became acquainted with Jesus as a young man
of about thirty years of age, if it is not blasphemy to speak of the age of a divine being. Now
the question regarding a witness is always whether he has seen or heard what he testifies
to. But the writers of these genealogies never assert that they heard the account from Jesus
Himself, nor even the fact of His birth; nor did they see Him till they came to know Him
after his baptism, many years after the time of His birth. To me, therefore, and to every
sensible man, it appears as foolish to believe this account, as it would be to call into court a
blind and deaf witness.
2. Augustin replied: As regards what Faustus calls his principal reason for not receiving
the genealogy of Jesus Christ, a complete refutation is found in the passages formerly quoted,
where Christ declares Himself to be the Son of man, and in what we have said of the identity
of the Son of man with the Son of God: that in His Godhead He has no earthly descent,
while after the flesh He is of the seed of David, as the apostle teaches. We are to believe,
therefore, that He came forth from the Father, that He descended from heaven, and also
that the Word was made flesh and dwelt amongst men. If the words, "Who is my mother,
and who are my brethren?"367 are quoted to show that Christ had no earthly mother or
descent, it follows that we must believe that His disciples, whom He here teaches by His
own example to set no value on earthly relationship, as compared with the kingdom of
heaven, had no fathers, because Christ says to them, "Call no man father upon earth; for
one is your Father, even God."368 What He taught them to do with reference to their fathers,
He Himself first did in reference to His own mother and brethren; as in many other things
He condescended to set us an example, and to go before that we might follow in His foot-
steps. Faustus’ principal objection to the genealogy fails completely; and after the defeat of
this invincible force, the rest is easily routed. He says that the apostles who declared Christ
to be the Son of man as well as the Son of God are not to be believed, because they were not
present at the birth of Christ, whom they joined when He had reached manhood, nor heard
of it from Christ Himself. Why then do they believe John when he says, "In the beginning
367 Matt. xii. 48.
368 Matt. xxiii. 9.
The genealogical question is again taken up and argued on both sides.
295
The genealogical question is again taken up and argued on both sides.