which I entirely agree with you. The word duty indeed, which you use when treating that
matter, is ordinarily supposed to signify the obligation the person is under by the divine
authority to believe, as applied to the matter of faith, and not to the act of faith put forth in
consequence of such obligation. Had I not supposed you plainly meant by the expressions
I quoted from the book, the duty or obligation to believe, and not an act of faith exerted, I
should have made no remarks on them. It is indeed as absurd for one to conclude he has
really believed without spiritual light or sight, as to say one should believe he had believed,
without those things that are essentially implied in faith. But I must differ from you in
thinking it is not very proper to say, it is a man’s duty to believe without faith, i.e. while he
yet remains without spiritual light or sight, or to put forth an act of faith on the Saviour,
however void of spiritual light or sight; for if this was not the truth, the finally impenitent
sinner could not be condemned for unbelief, as the Holy Ghost declares he will be, John iii.
19, 20, 24.. and that notwithstanding the power of the Spirit of faith must make him believe.
I should be glad to know the precise idea you affix to the words faith and believing. I do not
remember a person’s reflecting on his act of faith, any where in Scripture termed believing.
You remark, ‘That I seem to suppose that a person’s doubting of his good estate is the
proper opposite of faith;’ and I own, as it is a believer’s duty to expect salvation through
Christ, which, in other words, is to believe his good estate, Acts. xv. ll. Gal. ii. 20. Eph. ii. 4.
Job xix. 25. doubting of it must be his sin, an effect of unbelief, a part of it, and thus the
proper opposite of faith, considered in its full compass and latitude. Thus once doubting of
his good estate by a true believer, and unbelief in one branch of it, or one part and manner
of its acting, are the same thing. Faith and unbelief are opposed in Scripture, and what is
the opposite of one ingredient in unbelief must be faith in one part of it,—one thing that
belongs to its exercise. A person’s believing is owned to be his indispensable duty, and this
comprehends or supposes his being confident of his good estate, and is properly divine faith,
because it has the divine testimony now cited, on which it bottoms, Jer. iii. 19. The Lord
says, ‘Thou shalt call me, My father, and shalt not turn away from me;’ which is evidently
faith, and no less manifestly belief of one’s good estate, or being confident of it, because the
expression must denote the continued exercise of faith, in not turning away from the Lord.
Crying Abba Father, Rom. viii. 15. is faith in the Lord as one’s father, which must have a
being confident of one’s good estate inseparable from it, or rather enwrapped in it. I suppose
what I have mentioned is very consistent with what you say, ‘That faith, and persons believing
that they have faith, are not the same;’ for one’s believing that he has faith, simply and by
itself, has for its object the man’s inward frame, or the actings and exercises of his spirit,
and not a divine testimony. This is not divine faith; but, as I have laid the matter, a being
confident of one’s good estate has for its foundation the word of God, Heb. xiii. 5., &c. ulti-
mately,—at least; to be sure this is one way in which faith is acted, or one thing in its exercise.
I am far from thinking unbelief, or being without faith, and doubting whether they have
194
CHAPTER XV. Arrival of David Brainerd at Northampton. His sickness and…