the charge of Arianism by a great many prominent scholars; among others by Valesius in
his Life of Eusebius, by Bull (Def. Fid. Nic. II. 9. 20, III. 9. 3, 11), Cave (Lives of the Fathers,
II. p. 135 sq.), Fabricius (Bibl. Græc. VI. p. 32 sq.), Dupin (Bibl. Eccles. II. p. 7 sq.), and most
fully and carefully by Lee in his prolegomena to his edition of Eusebius’ Theophania, p. xxiv.
sq. Lightfoot also defends him against the charge of heresy, as do a great many other writers
whom it is not necessary to mention here. Confronted with such diversity of opinion, both
ancient and modern, what are we to conclude? It is useless to endeavor, as Lee does, to clear
Eusebius of all sympathy with and leaning toward Arianism. It is impossible to explain such
widespread and continued condemnation of him by acknowledging only that there are many
expressions in his works which are in themselves perfectly orthodox but capable of being
wrested in such a way as to produce a suspicion of possible Arianistic tendencies, for there
are such expressions in the works of multitudes of ancient writers whose orthodoxy has
never been questioned. Nor can the widespread belief that he was an Arian be explained by
admitting that he was for a time the personal friend of Arius, but denying that he accepted,
or in any way sympathized with his views (cf. Newman’s Arians, p. 262). There are in fact
certain fragments of epistles extant, which are, to say the least, decidedly Arianistic in their
modes of expression, and these must be reckoned with in forming an opinion of Eusebius’
views; for there is no reason to deny, as Lee does, that they are from Eusebius’ own hand.
On the other hand, to maintain, with some of the Fathers and many of the moderns, that
Eusebius was and continued through life a genuine Arian, will not do in the face of the facts
that contemporary and later Fathers were divided as to his orthodoxy, that he was honored
highly by the Church of subsequent centuries, except at certain periods, and was even can-
onized (see Lightfoot’s article, p. 348), that he solemnly signed the Nicene Creed, which
contained an express condemnation of the distinctive doctrines of Arius, and finally that at
least in his later works he is thoroughly orthodox in his expressions, and is explicit in his
rejection of the two main theses of the Arians,—that there was a time when the Son of God
was not, and that he was produced out of nothing. It is impossible to enter here into a detailed
discussion of such passages in Eusebius’ works as bear upon the subject under dispute. Lee
has considered many of them at great length, and the reader may be referred to him for
further information.
A careful examination of them will, I believe, serve to convince the candid student that
there is a distinction to be drawn between those works written before the rise of Arius, those
written between that time and the Council of Nicæa, and those written after the latter. It
has been very common to draw a distinction between those works written before and those
written after the Council, but no one, so far as I know, has distinguished those productions
of Eusebius’ pen which appeared between 318 and 325, and which were caused by the con-
troversy itself, from all his other writings. And yet such a distinction seems to furnish the
key to the problem. Eusebius’ opponents have drawn their strongest arguments from the
22
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.