§31. The observations made by watching Providence are sufficient to give us the knowledge
of sameness of Being.
And yet, if he could see the consequences of his own statements, he would be led on by
them to acquiesce in the doctrine of the Church. For if the maker’s nature is an indication
of the thing made, as he affirms, and if, according to his school, the Son is something made
by the Father, anyone who has observed the Father’s nature would have certainly known
thereby that of the Son; if, I say, it is true that the worker’s nature is a sign of that which he
works. But the Only-begotten, as they say, of the Father’s unlikeness, will be excluded from
76
operating through Providence. Eunomius need not trouble any more about His being gen-
erated, nor force out of that another proof of the son’s unlikeness. The difference of purpose
will itself be sufficient to bring to light His alien nature. For the First Being is, even by our
opponents’ confession, one and single, and necessarily His will must be thought of as follow-
ing the bent of His nature; but Providence shows that purpose is good, and so the nature
from which that purpose comes is shown to be good also. So the Father alone works good;
and the Son does not purpose the same things as He, if we adopt the assumptions of our
adversary; the difference then, of their nature will be clearly attested by this variation of
their purposes. But if, while the Father is provident for the Universe, the Son is equally
provident for it (for ‘what He sees the Father doing that also the Son does’), this sameness
of their purposes exhibits a communion of nature in those who thus purpose the same
things. Why, then, is all mention of Providence omitted by him, as if it would not help us
at all to that which we are searching for. Yet many familiar examples make for our view of
it. Anyone who has gazed on the brightness of fire and experienced its power of warming,
when he approaches another such brightness and another such warmth, will assuredly be
led on to think of fire; for his senses through the medium of these similar phænomena will
conduct him to the fact of a kindred element producing both; anything that was not fire
could not work on all occasions like fire. Just so, when we perceive a similar and equal
amount of providential power in the Father and in the Son, we make a guess by means of
what thus comes within the range of our knowledge about things which transcend our
comprehension; we feel that causes of an alien nature cannot be detected in these equal and
similar effects. As the observed phenomena are to each other, so will the subjects of those
phenomena be: if the first are opposed to each other, we must reckon the revealed entities
to be so too; if the first are alike, so too must those others be. Our Lord said allegorically
that their fruit is the sign of the characters of trees, meaning that it does not belie that
character, that the bad is not attached to the good tree, nor the good to the bad tree;—“by
their fruits ye shall know them;”—so when the fruit, Providence, presents no difference, we
detect a single nature from which that fruit has sprung, even though the trees be different
from which the fruit is put forth. Through that, then, which is cognizable by our apprehen-
sion, viz., the scheme or Providence visible in the Son in the same way as in the Father, the
The observations made by watching Providence are sufficient to give us the knowledge of sameness of Being.
144
The observations made by watching Providence are sufficient to give us the…