Introductory Notice
to
Two Epistles Concerning
Virginity.
By Professor M. B. Riddle,
D.D.
————————————
Among
the
“Pseudo-Clementina” the
Two Epistles concerning
Virginity
must properly be placed. The evidence against the
genuineness seems conclusive; yet, with the exception of the homily
usually styled the
Second Epistle of Clement
,
290
no spurious writings attributed to the great Roman Father can be
assigned an earlier date than these two letters. Uhlhorn, in view
of the reference to the
sub-introductæ
, thinks they were
written shortly before the time of Cyprian;
291
and
this seems very probable. Jerome was acquainted with the writings
(
Ad Jovinum
, i. 12), and possibly Epiphanius
(
Hær
., xxx. 15). Hence we may safely allow an early
date. Yet these evidences of age tell against the
genuineness.
1. Early works of this character would not have
disappeared from notice to such an extent, had they been authenticated
as writings of Clement. Supporting, as they do, the ascetic
tendency prevalent in the Western Church at and after the date when
they are first noticed by Christian writers, they would have been
carefully preserved and frequently cited, had they been genuine.
The name of the great Roman Father would have been so weighty, that the
advocates of celibacy would have kept the documents in greater
prominence. The silence of Eusebius respecting the letters is an
important fact in this discussion.
2. A second argument against the genuineness is
derived from the ascetic tone itself. Such pronounced statements
are not, we must firmly hold, to be found in the Christian literature
of the sub-apostolic age. This historical argument is further
sustained by other indications in the epistles. They point to a
stage of ecclesiastical development which belongs to a much later
period than that of Clement.
3. The use of Scripture in these letters seems to
be conclusive against the Clementine authorship. A comparison
with the citations in the genuine Epistle of Clement shows that these
writings make much greater use of the Pauline (particularly the
Pastoral) Epistles; that the Old Testament is less frequently cited,
and that the mode of handling proof-texts is that of a later age.
4. The judgment of the most candid patristic
scholars is against the genuineness. Of Protestants, Wetstein
stands alone in supporting the Clementine authorship; and his position
is readily explained by the fact that he discovered the Syriac version
which restored the writings to modern scholars (see below). The
genuineness is defended by Villecourt and Beelen (see below), also by
Möhler, Champagny, and Brück. But such experts as
Mansi, Hefele, Alzog, and Funk, among Roman Catholics, unite with
Protestant scholars in assigning a later date, and consequently in
denying the Clementine authorship.
Translator’s Introductory Notice.
While
the great mass of early
Christian literature bearing the name of Clement of Rome is undoubtedly
spurious, the case is somewhat different with regard to the two
following epistles. Not only have Roman Catholic writers
maintained their genuineness with great ingenuity and learning, but
Wetstein, who first edited them, argued powerfully for their being
received as the authentic productions of Clement; and even Neander has
admitted that they may possibly have been written by that friend and
fellow-labourer of the apostles.
Their literary history in modern times is somewhat
curious. Wetstein unexpectedly discovered them appended to a copy
of the Syriac Peschito version of the New Testament furnished to him by
Sir James Porter, then British ambassador at Constantinople. He
soon afterwards (1752) published them in Syriac, accompanied by a Latin
version of his own, with Prolegomena, in which he upheld their
genuineness. This speedily called forth two works, one by Lardner
(1753), and a second by Venema (1754), in both of which their
authenticity was disputed. To these writings Wetstein himself,
and, after his death, Gallandius, published rejoinders; but the
question remained as far from positive settlement as ever, and
continues
sub-judice
even at the present day
It is generally admitted (and, of course,
asserted
by those that maintain their truly Clementine origin)
that Greek was the original language of these epistles. Many have
argued that they contain plain references to the
sub-introductæ
spoken of in the literature of the third
century, and that therefore they were probably composed in the Oriental
Church about that period.
These epistles have been very carefully edited in recent
times by the Roman Catholic scholars Villecourt (1853) and Beelen
(1856). Both have argued strenuously for the genuineness of the
letters, but it may be doubted if they have succeeded in repelling all
the objections of Lardner and Venema. Beelen’s work is a
highly scholarly production, and his Prolegomena are marked by great
fulness and perspicuity.
A German translation of these epistles was published by
Zingerle (1821). They are now for the first time translated into
the English language.
The translation is made from the text of Beelen.
The division into chapters is due to
Wetstein.
290
See vol. vii. pp.
509–523.
291
Against this
class Cyprian stoutly contended. Comp. Cyprian,
Ante-Nicene
Fathers
, vol. v. pp. 357, 358, 587–592.