180
escape the cosmic powers, as they called them, in no other way than by discharging their
obligations to them all by infamous conduct.
10. Thus it came to pass that the malignant demon, making use of these ministers, on
the one hand enslaved those that were so pitiably led astray by them to their own destruction,
while on the other hand he furnished to the unbelieving heathen abundant opportunities
for slandering the divine word, inasmuch as the reputation of these men brought infamy
upon the whole race of Christians.
11. In this way, therefore, it came to pass that there was spread abroad in regard to us
among the unbelievers of that age, the infamous and most absurd suspicion that we practiced
unlawful commerce with mothers and sisters, and enjoyed impious feasts.1034
12. He did not, however, long succeed in these artifices, as the truth established itself
and in time shone with great brilliancy.
13. For the machinations of its enemies were refuted by its power and speedily vanished.
One new heresy arose after another, and the former ones always passed away, and now at
one time, now at another, now in one way, now in other ways, were lost in ideas of various
kinds and various forms. But the splendor of the catholic and only true Church, which is
always the same, grew in magnitude and power, and reflected its piety and simplicity and
freedom, and the modesty and purity of its inspired life and philosophy to every nation both
of Greeks and of Barbarians.
14. At the same time the slanderous accusations which had been brought against the
whole Church1035 also vanished, and there remained our teaching alone, which has prevailed
1034 The chief accusations urged against the early Christians by their antagonists were atheism, cannibalism,
and incest. These charges were made very early. Justin Martyr (Apol. I. 26) mentions them, and Pliny in his
epistle to Trajan speaks of the innocent meals of the Christians, implying that they had been accused of immor-
ality in connection with them. (Compare, also, Tertullian’s Apol. 7, 8, and Ad Nationes, 7.) In fact, suspicions
arose among the heathen as soon as their love feasts became secret. The persecution in Lyons is to be explained
only by the belief of the officers that these and similar accusations were true. The Christians commonly denied
all such charges in toto, and supported their denial by urging the absurdity of such conduct; but sometimes, as
in the present case, they endeavored to exonerate themselves by attributing the crimes with which they were
charged to heretics. This course, however, helped them little with the heathen, as the latter did not distinguish
between the various parties of Christians, but treated them all as one class. The statement of Eusebius in the
present case is noteworthy. He thinks that the crimes were really committed by heretics, and occasioned the
accusations of the heathen, and he thus admits that the charges were founded upon fact. In this case he acts toward
the heretics in the same way that the heathen acted toward the Christians as a whole. This method of exonerating
themselves appears as early as Justin Martyr (compare his Apol. I. 26). Irenæus also (I. 25, 3), whom Eusebius
substantially follows in this passage, and Philaster (c. 57), pursue the same course.
1035 Eusebius is correct in his statement that such accusations were no longer made in his day. The Church
had, in fact, lived them down completely. It is noticeable that in the elaborate work of Celsus against the Chris-
395
The Persons that became at that Time Leaders of Knowledge falsely so-ca…