On Bk. VI. chap. 23, § 4 (note 6). Origen’s Visit to Achaia.
Eusebius gives as the cause of Origen’s visit to Greece simply “a pressing necessity in
connection with ecclesiastical affairs,” but Jerome (de vir. ill. c. 54) tells us that it was on
account of heresies which were troubling the churches of Achaia (propter ecclesias Achaiæ,
quæ pluribus hæresibus vexabantur). Photius (Cod. 118) reports that Origen went to Athens
396
without the consent of Demetrius (χωρὶς τῆς τοῦ οἰκείου γνώμης ἐπισκόπου), but this must
be regarded as a mistake (caused perhaps by his knowledge that it was Origen’s ordination,
which took place during this trip, that caused Demetrius’ anger; for Photius does not say
that this statement rests upon the authority of Pamphilus, but prefaces his whole account
with the words ὁ τε Π€μφιλος μ€ρτυς καὶ ἕτεροι πλεῖστοι), for Jerome (de vir. ill. c. 54) says
that Origen went to Athens by way of Palestine sub testimonio ecclesiasticæ epistolæ, and in
chap. 62 he says that Alexander, bishop of Jerusalem wrote an epistle in which he stated that
he had ordained Origen juxta testimonium Demetrii. We must therefore assume that Origen
left Alexandria for Athens with Demetrius’ approval, and with letters of recommendation
from him. It is the common opinion that Origen left Alexandria this time about 228 a.d.,
and after his visit in Achaia returned to Alexandria, where he remained until excommunicated
by the council called by Demetrius. Upon searching the sources, however, I can find abso-
lutely no authority for the statement that he returned to Alexandria after his visit to Achaia;
in fact, that he did seems by most scholars simply to be taken for granted without further
investigation. The opinion apparently rests upon the interpretation of two passages, one in
a report of the proceedings of the Alexandrian synod taken by Photius from Pamphilus’
Apology, the other in the preface to the sixth book of Origen’s commentary on the Gospel
of John. In the former it is said that the synod voted to exile Origen from Alexandria, and
forbade him to reside or to teach there (ψηφίζεται μεταστῆναι μὲν ἀπὸ ᾽Αλεξανδρείας τὸν
᾽Ωριγένην, καὶ μήτε διατρίβειν ἐν αὐτῇ, μήτε διδ€σκειν). But certainly such a decree is far
from proving that Origen, at the time it was passed, was actually in Alexandria. It simply
shows that he still regarded that city as his residence, and was supposed to be expecting to
return to it after his visit was completed. In the preface to the sixth book of his commentary
on John’s Gospel, he speaks of the troubles and trials which he had been enduring in Alex-
andria before he finally left the city, and compares that departure to the exodus of the children
of Israel. But certainly it is just as easy to refer these troubles to the time before his visit to
Achaia, a time when in all probability the early books of his commentary on John, as well
as others of his writings, had begun to excite the hostility of the Alexandrian clergy, and
thus made his residence there uncomfortable. It is almost necessary to assume that this
hostility had arisen some time before the synods were held, in order to account both for the
hostility of the majority of the clergy, which cannot have been so seriously aroused in an
instant, and also for the change in Demetrius’ attitude, which must have found a partial
cause in the already existing hostility of the clergy to Origen, hostility which led them to
On Bk. VI. chap. 23, § 4 (note 6). Origen's Visit to Achaia.
1014
On Bk. VI. chap. 23, § 4 (note 6). Origen's Visit to Achaia.