but with regard to the impracticability of their own contention they are as incapable of vision
as men who deliberately close their eyes. For who but one whose mental optics are utterly
purblind can fail to discern the loose and unsubstantial character of the principle of their
doctrine, and that their argument in support of ungeneracy as an essence has nothing to
stand upon? For this is the way in which their error would establish itself.
But to the best of my ability I will raise my voice to rebut our enemies’ argument. They
say that God is declared to be without generation, that the Godhead is by nature simple,
and that which is simple admits of no composition. If, then, God Who is declared to be
without generation is by His nature without composition, His title of Ungenerate must belong
to His very nature, and that nature is identical with ungeneracy. To whom we reply that the
terms incomposite and ungenerate are not the same thing, for the former represents the
simplicity of the subject, the other its being without origin, and these expressions are not
convertible in meaning, though both are predicated of one subject. But from the appellation
of Ungenerate we have been taught that He Who is so named is without origin, and from
the appellation of simple that He is free from all admixture (or composition), and these
terms cannot be substituted for each other. There is therefore no necessity that, because the
Godhead is by its nature simple, that nature should be termed ungeneracy; but in that He
is indivisible and without composition, He is spoken of as simple, while in that He was not
generated, He is spoken of as ungenerate.
Now if the term ungenerate did not signify the being without origin, but the idea of
simplicity entered into the meaning of such a term, and He were called ungenerate in their
heretical sense, merely because He is simple and incomposite, and if the terms simple and
ungenerate are the same in meaning, then too must the simplicity of the Son be equivalent
with ungeneracy. For they will not deny that God the Only-begotten is by His nature simple,
unless they are prepared to deny that He is God. Accordingly the term simplicity will in its
meaning have no such connection with being ungenerate as that, by reason of its incomposite
character, His nature should be termed ungeneracy; or they draw upon themselves one of
two absurd alternatives, either denying the Godhead of the Only-begotten, or attributing
ungeneracy to Him also. For if God is simple, and the term simplicity is, according to them,
identical with ungenerate, they must either make out the Son to be of composite nature, by
which term it is implied that neither is He God, or if they allow His Godhead, and God (as
253
I have said) is simple, then they make Him out at the same time to be ungenerate, if the
terms simple and ungenerate are convertible. But to make my meaning clearer I will recapit-
ulate. We affirm that each of these terms has its own peculiar meaning, and that the term
indivisible cannot be rendered by ungenerate, nor ungenerate by simple; but by simple we
understand uncompounded, and by ungenerate we are taught to understand what is without
origin. Furthermore we hold that we are bound to believe that the Son of God, being Himself
God, is Himself also simple, because God is free from all compositeness; and in like manner
481
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.