22. You err, my opponent says, and are deceived; for the gods are not themselves artificers,
but suggest these arts to ingenious men, and teach mortals what they should know, that
their mode of life may be more civilized. But he who gives any instruction to the ignorant
470
and unwilling, and strives to make him intelligently expert in some kind of work, must
himself first know that which he sets the other to practise. For no one can be capable of
teaching a science without knowing the rules of that which he teaches, and having grasped
its method most thoroughly. The gods are, then, the first artificers; whether because they
inform the minds of men with knowledge, as you say yourselves, or because, being immortal
and unbegotten, they surpass the whole race of earth by their length of life.3982 This, then,
is the question; there being no occasion for these arts among the gods, neither their neces-
sities nor nature requiring in them any ingenuity or mechanical skill, why you should say
that they are skilled,3983 one in one craft, another in another, and that individuals are pre-
eminently expert3984 in particular departments in which they are distinguished by acquaint-
ance with the several branches of science?
3982 Lit., “by the long duration of time.”
3983 Lit., “skilled in notions”—perceptionibus; for which præceptionibus, i.e., “the precepts of the different
arts,” has been suggested in the margin of Ursinus.
3984 Lit., “and have skill (sollertias) in which individuals excel.”
Chapter XXII.
1109
Chapter XXII.