other collections, and particularly into that of the pseudo-Isidore; and in 1054, Humbert,
legate of Pope Leo IX., made the following declaration: Clementis libel, id est itinerarium
Petri Apostoli et Canones Apostolorum numerantur inter apocrypha, Exceptis Capitulis
Quisquaginta, quæ decreverunt regulis orthodoxis adjungenda. Gratian also, in his decree,
borrowed from the fifty Apostolic Canons, and they gradually obtained the force of laws.
But many writers, especially Hincmar of Rheims, like Dionysius Exiguus, raised doubts
upon the apostolical origin of these canons. From the sixteenth century the opinion has
been universal that these documents are not authentic; with the exception, however, of the
French Jesuit Turrianus, who endeavoured to defend their genuineness, as well as the au-
thenticity of the pseudo-Isidorian decrees. According to the Centuriators of Magdeburg,
it was especially Gabriel d’Aubespine, Bishop of Orleans, the celebrated Archbishop Peter
de Marca, and the Anglican Beveridge, who proved that they were not really compiled by
the Apostles, but were made partly in the second and chiefly in the third century. Beveridge
considered this collection to be a repertory of ancient canons given by synods in the second
and third centuries. In opposition to them, the Calvinist Dallæus (Daillé) regarded it as the
work of a forger who lived in the fifth and sixth centuries; but Beveridge refuted him so
convincingly, that from that time his opinion, with some few modifications, has been that
of all the learned.
Beveridge begins with the principle, that the Church in the very earliest times must have
had a collection of canons; and he demonstrates that from the commencement of the fourth
century, bishops, synods, and other authorities often quote, as documents in common use,
a κανὼν αποστολικὸς, or ἐκκλησιαστικὸς, or ἀρχαῖος; as was done, for instance, at the
Council of Nice, by Alexander, Bishop of Alexandria, and by the Emperor Constantine,
etc.563 According to Beveridge, these quotations make allusion to the Apostolic Canons,
and prove that they were already in use before the fourth century.
In opposition to Beveridge Dr. von Drey wrote with profound learning;564 and Bickell,
in his work just quoted, to a great degree accepts his conclusions as being well-founded.
These conclusions in short are that the so-called “Apostolic Canons” are a patchwork
taken from the “Apostolic Constitutions,” which are said to have been of Eastern origin and
to date from the latter part of the third century, and from the canons of various synods,
notably Nice, Antioch, and Chalcedon.
But this last reference to Chalcedon is too much for Bickell to stomach; and for many
reasons he makes the date of the collection earlier.
Hefele points out a rather significant document which he says both “Drey and Bickell
have overlooked. In 1738 Scipio Maffei published three ancient documents, the first of
563 Cf. (for catena) Bickell, Geschichte des Kirchenrechts, S. 82.
564 Neue Untersuchungen über die Const. und Canones der Apostel. Tübing., 1832.
1085
The Apostolical Canons. Introduction.