Yea, these notions, which suppose moral necessity and inability to be inconsistent with
blame or moral obligation, will directly lead men to justify the vilest acts and practices, from
the strength of their wicked inclinations of all sorts; strong inclinations inducing a moral
necessity; yea, to excuse every degree of evil inclination, so far as this has evidently prevailed,
and been the thing which has determined their Wills: because, so far as antecedent inclination
determined the Will, so far the Will was without liberty of indifference and self-determina-
tion. Which, at last, will come to this, that men will justify themselves in all the wickedness
they commit. It has been observed already, that this scheme of things exceedingly diminishes
the guilt of sin, and the difference between the greatest and smallest offences; 157 and if it
be pursued in its real consequences, it leaves room for no such thing, as either virtue or vice,
blame or praise in the world. 158 And again, how naturally does this notion of the sovereign
self-determining power of the Will, in all things virtuous or vicious, and whatsoever deserves
either reward or punishment, tend to encourage men to put off the work of religion and
virtue, and turning from sin to God; since they have a sovereign power to determine them-
selves, just when they please; or if not, they are wholly excusable in going on in sin, because
of their inability to do any other.
If it should be said, that the tendency of this doctrine of necessity to licentiousness, ap-
pears by the improvement many at this day actually make of it, to justify themselves in their
dissolute courses; I will not deny that some men do unreasonably abuse this doctrine, as
they do many other things, which are true and excellent in their own nature: but I deny,
that this proves the doctrine itself has any tendency to licentiousness. I think, the tendency
of doctrines, by what now appears in the world, and in our nation in particular, may much
more justly be argued, from the general effect which has been seen to attend the prevailing
of the principles of Arminians, and the contrary principles; as both have had their turn of
general prevalence in our nation. If it be indeed, as is pretended, that Calvinistic doctrines
undermine the very foundation of all religion and morality, and enervate and disannul all
rational motives to holy and virtuous practice; and that the contrary doctrines give the in-
ducements to virtue and goodness their proper force, and exhibit religion in a rational light,
tending to recommend it to the reason of mankind, and enforce it in a manner that is
agreeable to their natural notions of things: I say, if it be thus, it is remarkable, that virtue
and religious practice should prevail most, when the former doctrines, so inconsistent with
it, prevailed almost universally: and that ever since the latter doctrines, so happily agreeing
with it, and of so proper and excellent a tendency to promote it, have been gradually prevail-
157 Part III Sect VI.
158 Part III Sect VI. Ibid Sect VII. Part IV. Sect. I. Part. III. Sect. III. Corol 1. after the first head
753
SECTION XII. Of a supposed tendency of these principles to Atheism and…