2. And at the same time Papias,907 bishop of the parish of Hierapolis,908 became well
known, as did also Ignatius, who was chosen bishop of Antioch, second in succession to
Peter, and whose fame is still celebrated by a great many.909
907 Of the life of Papias, bishop of Hierapolis, we know very little. He is mentioned by Irenæus, Adv. Hær.
V. 33. 3 and 4, who informs us that he was a companion of Polycarp and a hearer of the apostle John. The latter
statement is in all probability incorrect (see chap. 39. note 4): but there is no reason to question the truth of the
former. Papias’ dates we cannot ascertain with any great degree of accuracy. A notice in the Chron. Paschale,
which makes him a martyr and connects his death with that of Polycarp, assigning both to the year 164 a.d. has
been shown by Lightfoot (Contemp. Review, 1875, II. p. 381) to rest upon a confusion of names, and to be,
therefore, entirely untrustworthy. We learn, however, from chap. 39, below, that Papias was acquainted with
personal followers of the Lord (e.g. with Aristion and the “presbyter John”), and also with the daughters of
Philip. He must, therefore, have reached years of maturity before the end of the first century. On the other hand,
the five books of his Expositions cannot have been written very long before the middle of the second century,
for some of the extant fragments seem to show traces of the existence of Gnosticism in a somewhat advanced
form at the time he wrote. With these data we shall not be far wrong in saying that he was born in the neighbor-
hood of 70 a.d., and died before the middle of the second century. He was a pronounced chiliast (see chap. 39,
note 19), and according to Eusebius, a man of limited understanding (see chap. 39, note 20); but the claim of
the Tübingen school that he was an Ebionite is not supported by extant evidence (see Lightfoot, ibid. p. 384).
On the writings of Papias, see below, chap. 39, note 1.
908 Four mss. insert at this point the words ἀνὴρ τὰ π€ντα ὅτι μ€λιστα λογιώτατος καὶ τῆς γραφῆς εἰδήμων
(“a man of the greatest learning in all lines and well versed in the Scriptures”), which are accepted by Heinichen,
Closs, and Crusè. The large majority of the best mss., however, supported by Rufinus, and followed by Valesius
(in his notes), Stroth, Laemmer, Burton, and the German translator, Stigloher, omit the words, which are un-
doubtedly to be regarded as an interpolation, intended perhaps to offset the derogatory words used by Eusebius
in respect to Papias in chap. 39, §13. In discussing the genuineness of these words, critics (among them Heinichen)
have concerned themselves too much with the question whether the opinion of Papias expressed here contradicts
that expressed in chap. 39, and therefore, whether Eusebius can have written these words. Even if it be possible
to reconcile the two passages and to show that Papias may have been a learned man, while at the same time he
was of “limited judgment,” as Eusebius informs us, the fact nevertheless remains that the weight of ms. authority
is heavily against the genuineness of the words, and that it is much easier to understand the interpolation than
the omission of such an expression in praise of one of the apostolic Fathers, especially when the lack of any
commendation here and in chap. 39 must be unpleasantly noticeable.
909 Eusebius follows what was undoubtedly the oldest tradition in making Evodius the first bishop of Antioch,
and Ignatius the second (see above, chap. 22, note 2). Granting the genuineness of the shorter Greek recension
of the Ignatian epistles (to be mentioned below), the fact that Ignatius was bishop of the church of Antioch in
Syria is established by Ep. ad Rom. 9, compared with ad Smyr. 11 and ad Polycarp. 7. If the genuineness of the
epistles be denied, these passages seem to prove at least his connection with the church of Antioch and his influ-
ential position in it, for otherwise the forgery of the epistles under his name would be inconceivable. There are
359
Ignatius and His Epistles.