328 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Boox vir.
are jet-black. Do you, then, sacrifice to the gods only wool
and little bristles torn from the victims? Do you leave the
wretched creatures, despoiled it may be, and shorn, to draw the
breath of heaven, and rest in perfect innocence upon their feed-
ing-grounds? But if you think that those things are pleasing
to the infernal gods which are black and of a gloomy colour,
why do you not take care that all the other things which it
is customary to place upon their sacrifices should be black,
and smoked, and horrible in colour? Dye the incense if it
is offered, the salted grits, and all the libations without ex-
ception. Into the milk, oil, blood, pour soot and ashes, that
this may lose its purple hue, that the others may become
ghastly. But if you have no scruple in introducing some
things which are white and retain their brightness, you
yourselves do away with your own religious scruples and
reasonings, while you do not maintain any single and uni-
versal rule in performing the sacred rites.
21. But this, too, it is fitting that we should here learn
from you: If a goat be slain to Jupiter, which is usually
sacrificed to father Liber and Mercury,’ or if the barren
heifer be sacrificed to Unxia, which you give to Proserpine,
by what usage and rule is it determined what crime there is
in this, what wickedness or guilt has been contracted, since
it makes no difference to the worship [offered to the deity]
what animal it is with whose head the honour is paid which
you owe? It is not lawful, says [my opponent], that these
things should be confounded, and it is no small crime to
throw the ceremonies of the rites and the mode of expiation
into confusion. Explain the reason, I beg. Because it is
right to consecrate victims of a certain kind to certain
deities, and that certain forms of supplication should be also
adopted. And what, again, is the reason that it is right to
consecrate victims of'a certain kind to certain deities, and
that certain forms of supplication should be also adopted,
for this very rightfulness should have its own cause, and
spring, be derived from certain reasons? Are you going
1 Goats were sacrificed to Bacchus, but not, so far as is known, to
Mercury. Cf. c. 16, p. 323, n. 5.