by their notion of freedom, are so plainly and abundantly taught in the Scripture. But I am
under no apprehensions of any danger, which the cause of Christianity, or the religion of
the reformed, is in, from any possibility of that notion being ever established, or of its being
ever evinced that there is not proper, perfect, and manifold demonstration lying against it.
But as I said, it would be needless for me to enter into a particular disquisition of this point
here; from which I shall easily be excused by any reader who is willing to give himself the
trouble of consulting what I have already written. And as to others, probably they will scarce
be at the pains of reading the present discourse; or at least would not, if it should be enlarged
by a full consideration of that controversy.
I shall at this time therefore only take notice of some gross inconsistencies that Dr. T.
has been guilty of, in his handling this objection against the doctrine of original sin. In places
which have been cited, he says, that sin must proceed from our own choice: and that if it does
not, it being necessary to us, it cannot be sin, it cannot be our fault, or what we are to blame
for: and therefore all our sin must be chargeable on our choice, which is the cause of sin: for
he says, the cause of every effect is alone chargeable with the effect it produceth, and which
proceedeth from it. 129 Now here are implied several gross contradictions. He greatly insists.,
that nothing can be sinful, or have the nature of sin, but what proceeds from our choice.
Nevertheless he says, “Not the effect, but the cause alone is chargeable with blame.“ Therefore
the choice, which is the cause, is alone blamable, or has the nature of sin; and not the effect
of that choice. Thus nothing can be sinful, but the effect of choice; and yet the effect of choice
never can be sinful, but only the cause, which alone is chargeable with all the blame.
Again, the choice, from which sin proceeds, is itself sinful. Not only is this implied in
his saying, “The cause alone is chargeable with all the blame;” but he expressly speaks of the
choice as faulty, 130 and calls that choice wicked, from which depravity and corruption pro-
ceeds. 131 Now if the choice itself be sin, and there be no sin but what proceeds from a sinful
choice, then the sinful choice must proceed from another antecedent choice; it must he
chosen by a foregoing act of will, determining itself to that sinful choice, that so it may have
that which he speaks of as absolutely essential to the nature of sin, namely, that it proceeds
from our choice, and does not happen to us necessarily. But if the sinful choice itself proceeds
from a foregoing choice, then also that foregoing choice must be sinful; it being the cause
of sin, and so alone chargeable with the blame. Yet if that foregoing choice be sinful, then
neither must that happen to us necessarily, but must like-wise proceed from choice, another
act of choice preceding that: for we must remember, that “Nothing is sinful but what proceeds
from our choice.“ And then, for the same reason, even this prior choice, last mentioned,
129 Page. 128
130 Page 190.
131 Page 200. See also p. 216.
1135
PART IV. Containing Answers to Objections.