Now just as we cannot name the material of the iron from the quality now to be observed
upon it (for we do not give the name of fire or ice to that which is tempered with either of
these), so the moment we grant the view of these heretics, that in the case121 of the Life-
giving Power good does not reside in It essentially, but is imparted to it only, it will become
62
impossible to call it properly good: such a conception of it will compel us to regard it as
something different, as not eternally exhibiting the good, as not in itself to be classed amongst
genuine goods, but as such that the good is at times not in it, and is at times not likely to be
in it. If these existences become good only by sharing in a something superior to themselves,
it is plain that before this participation they were not good, and if, being other than good,
they were then coloured by the influence of good they must certainly, if again isolated from
this, be considered other than good: so that, if this heresy prevails, the Divine Nature cannot
be apprehended as transmissive of good, but rather as itself needing goodness: for how can
one impart to another that which he does not himself possess? If it is in a state of perfection,
no abatement of that can be conceived, and it is absurd to talk of less of perfection. If on the
other hand its participation of good is an imperfect one, and this is what they mean by ‘less,’
mark the consequence that anything in that state can never help an inferior, but will be
busied in satisfying its own want: so that, according to them, Providence is a fiction, and so
is the judgment and the Dispensation of the Only-begotten, and all the other works believed
to be done, and still doing by Him: for He will necessarily be employed in taking care of His
own good, and must abandon the supervision of the Universe122.
If, then, this surmise is to have its way, namely, that our Lord is not perfected in every
kind of good, it is very easy to see the conclusion of the blasphemy. This being so, our faith
is vain, and our preaching vain; our hopes, which take their substance from our faith, are
unsubstantial. Why are they baptized into Christ123, if He has no power of goodness of His
own? God forgive me for saying it! Why do they believe in the Holy Ghost, if the same ac-
count is given of Him? How are they regenerate124 by baptism from their mortal birth, if
the regenerating Power does not possess in its own nature infallibility and independence?
How can their ‘vile body’ be changed, while they think that He who is to change it Himself
121 τῆς ζωοποιοῦ δυνάμεως.
122 τοῦ παντὸς. It is worth while to mention, once for all, the distinction in the names used by the Stoics for
the world, which had long since passed from them into the common parlance. Including the Empty, the world
is called τὸ πᾶν, without it, ὅλον (τὸ ὅλον, τὰ ὅλα frequently occurs with the Stoics). The πᾶν, it was said, is
neither material nor immaterial, since it consists of both.
123 Τί γὰρ βαπτίζονται εἰς Χριστὸν. This throws some light on the much discussed passage, ‘Why are these
baptized for the dead?’ Gregory at all events seems here to take it to mean, ‘Why are they baptized in the name
of a dead Christ?’ as he is adopting partially S. Paul’s words, 1 Cor. xv. 29; as well as Heb. xi. 1 above.
124 ἀναγεννῶνται
117
He has no right to assert a greater and less in the Divine being. A systematic…