against vice. But I think the case is evidently otherwise. Some men, through the strength of
vice in their hearts, will go on and sin against clearer light and stronger convictions of con-
science than others. If conscience, approving duty and disapproving sin, were the same
thing as the exercise of a virtuous principle of the heart, in loving duty and hating sin, then
remorse of conscience will be the same thing as repentance; and just in the same degree as
the sinner feels remorse of conscience for sin, in the same degree is the heart turned from
the love of sin to the hatred of it, inasmuch as they are the very same thing.
Christians have the greatest reason to believe, from the Scriptures, that in the future
day of the revelation of the righteous judgment of God, when sinners shall be called to answer
before their judge, and all their wickedness, in all its aggravations, brought forth, and clearly
manifested in the perfect light of that day, and God will reprove them and set their sins in
order before them, their consciences will be greatly awakened and convinced, their mouths
will be stopped, all stupidity of conscience will be at an end, and conscience will have its full
exercise; and therefore their consciences will approve the dreadful sentence of the judge
against them; and seeing that they have deserved so great a punishment, will join with the
judge in condemning them. And this, according to the notion I am opposing, would be the
same thing as their being brought to the fullest repentance; their hearts being perfectly
changed to hate sin and love holiness; and virtue or holiness of heart in them will be brought
to the most full and perfect exercise. But how much otherwise have we reason to suppose
it will then be! Then the sin and wickedness of their heart will come to its highest dominion
and completest exercise; they shall be wholly left of God, and given up to their wickedness,
even as the devils are! When God has done waiting on sinners, and his Spirit done striving
with them, he will not restrain their wickedness, as he does now. But sin shall then rage in
their hearts, as a fire no longer restrained or kept under. It is proper for a judge when he
condemns a criminal, to endeavour so to set his guilt before him as to convince his conscience
of the justice of the sentence. This the Almighty will do effectually, and do to perfection, so
as most thoroughly to awaken and convince the conscience. But if natural conscience, and
the disposition of the heart to be pleased with virtue, were the same, then at the same time
that the conscience was brought to its perfect exercise, the heart would be made perfectly
holy; or, would have the exercise of true virtue and holiness in perfect benevolence of temper.
But instead of this, their wickedness will then be brought to perfection, and wicked men
will become very devils, and accordingly will be sent away as cursed into everlasting fire
prepared for the devil and his angels.
But supposing natural conscience to be what has been described, all these difficulties
and absurdities are wholly avoided. Sinners when they see the greatness of the Being in
contempt of whom they have lived with rebellion and opposition, and have clearly set before
them their obligations to him, as their Creator, Preserver, Benefactor, &c. together with the
degree in which they have acted as enemies to him, may have a clear sense of the desert of
901
CHAPTER V. Natural conscience, and the moral sense.