Chapter 19.—Against the Opinion of Those Who Do Not Believe that the Primitive
Men Would Have Been Immortal If They Had Not Sinned.
At present let us go on, as we have begun, to give some explanation regarding the bodies
of our first parents. I say then, that, except as the just consequence of sin, they would not
have been subjected even to this death, which is good to the good,—this death, which is not
exclusively known and believed in by a few, but is known to all, by which soul and body are
separated, and by which the body of an animal which was but now visibly living is now
visibly dead. For though there can be no manner of doubt that the souls of the just and holy
dead live in peaceful rest, yet so much better would it be for them to be alive in healthy,
255
well-conditioned bodies, that even those who hold the tenet that it is most blessed to be
quit of every kind of body, condemn this opinion in spite of themselves. For no one will
dare to set wise men, whether yet to die or already dead,—in other words, whether already
quit of the body, or shortly to be so,—above the immortal gods, to whom the Supreme, in
Plato, promises as a munificent gift life indissoluble, or in eternal union with their bodies.
But this same Plato thinks that nothing better can happen to men than that they pass through
life piously and justly, and, being separated from their bodies, be received into the bosom
of the gods, who never abandon theirs; “that, oblivious of the past, they may revisit the upper
air, and conceive the longing to return again to the body.”602 Virgil is applauded for bor-
rowing this from the Platonic system. Assuredly Plato thinks that the souls of mortals cannot
always be in their bodies, but must necessarily be dismissed by death; and, on the other
hand, he thinks that without bodies they cannot endure for ever, but with ceaseless alternation
pass from life to death, and from death to life. This difference, however, he sets between
wise men and the rest, that they are carried after death to the stars, that each man may repose
for a while in a star suitable for him, and may thence return to the labors and miseries of
mortals when he has become oblivious of his former misery, and possessed with the desire
of being embodied. Those, again, who have lived foolishly transmigrate into bodies fit for
them, whether human or bestial. Thus he has appointed even the good and wise souls to a
very hard lot indeed, since they do not receive such bodies as they might always and even
immortally inhabit, but such only as they can neither permanently retain nor enjoy eternal
purity without. Of this notion of Plato’s, we have in a former book already said603 that
Porphyry was ashamed in the light of these Christian times, so that he not only emancipated
human souls from a destiny in the bodies of beasts but also contended for the liberation of
the souls of the wise from all bodily ties, so that, escaping from all flesh, they might, as bare
and blessed souls, dwell with the Father time without end. And that he might not seem to
be outbid by Christ’s promise of life everlasting to His saints, he also established purified
602 Virgil, Æn, vi. 750, 751.
603 Book x. 30.
Against the Opinion of Those Who Do Not Believe that the Primitive Men Would Have Been Immortal If They Had Not Sinned.
582
Against the Opinion of Those Who Do Not Believe that the Primitive Men Would…