which Christ is; of which way the Psalmist thus speaks: “God be merciful unto us, and bless
us, and cause His face to shine upon us: that Thy way may be known upon earth, Thy saving
health among all nations.”2253
36. In the next place, if you are charmed by the authority of that bishop and illustrious
martyr St. Cyprian, which we indeed regard, as I have said, as quite distinct from the authority
of canonical Scripture, why are you not charmed by such things in him as these: that he
maintained with loyalty, and defended in debate, the unity of the Church in the world and
in all nations; that he censured, as full of self-sufficiency and pride, those who wished to
separate themselves as righteous from the Church, holding them up to ridicule for assuming
to themselves that which the Lord did not concede even to apostles,—namely, the gathering
of the tares before the harvest,—and for attempting to separate the chaff from the wheat, as
if to them had been assigned the charge of removing the chaff and cleansing the threshing-
floor; that he proved that no man can be stained with guilt by the sins of others, thus
sweeping away the only ground alleged by the authors of schism for their separation; that
in the very matter in regard to which he was of a different opinion from his colleagues, he
did not decree that those who thought otherwise than he did should be condemned or ex-
communicated; that even in his letter to Jubaianus2254 (which was read for the first time in
the Council,2255 the authority of which you are wont to plead in defence of the practice of
rebaptizing), although he admits that in time past persons who had been baptized in other
communions had been received into the Church without being a second time baptized, on
which ground they were regarded by him as having had no baptism, nevertheless he considers
the use and benefit of peace within the Church to be so great, that for its sake he holds that
these persons (though in his judgment unbaptized) should not be excluded from office in
the Church?
37. And by this you will very readily perceive (for I know the acuteness of your mind)
that your cause is completely subverted and annihilated. For if, as you suppose, the Church
which had been spread abroad throughout the world perished through her admitting sinners
to partake in her sacraments (and this is the ground alleged for your separation), it had
wholly perished long before,—at the time, namely, when, as Cyprian says, men were admitted
into it without baptism,—and thus Cyprian himself had no Church within which to be born;
and if so, how much more must this have been the case with one who, like Donatus, the
author of your schism, and the father of your sect, belonged to a later age! But if at that time,
although persons were being admitted into the Church without baptism, the Church never-
theless remained in being, so as to give birth to Cyprian and afterwards to Donatus, it is
2253 Ps. lxvii. 1, 2.
2254 See Ante-Nicene Fathers, Am. ed. vol. v. p. 379.
2255 Held at Carthage, A.D. 256.
870
To Vincentius