Chapter X.—Of those who reject the Doctrines of Philosophers, as well as those of Scripture:
and that we ought to believe the Poets in All Things, or disbelieve them in All.
There are, however, some persons so infatuated, that when they meet with such senti-
ments as these, they are neither converted or alarmed: nay, they even treat them with con-
tempt and scorn, as if they listened to the inventions of fable; applauding, perhaps, the beauty
of the eloquence, but abhorring the severity of the precepts. And yet they give credence to
the fictions of the poets, and make both civilized and barbarous3410 countries ring with ex-
ploded and false tales. For the poets assert that the judgment of souls after death is committed
to men whose parentage they ascribe to the gods,3411 extolling their righteousness and im-
partiality and represent them as guardians of the dead. The same poets describe the battles
of the gods and certain usages of war among them, and speak of them as subject to the power
of fate. Some of these deities they picture to us as cruel, others as strangers to all care for
the human race, and others again as hateful in their character. They introduce them also as
mourning the slaughter of their own children, thus implying their inability to succor, not
strangers merely, but those most dear to them. They describe them, too, as subject to human
passions, and sing of their battles and wounds, their joys and sorrows. And in all this they
appear worthy of belief.3412 For if we suppose them to be moved by a divine impulse to at-
tempt the poetic art, we are bound to believe them and to be persuaded of what they utter
under this inspiration. They speak, then, of the calamities to which their divinities are subject;
calamities which of course are altogether true! But it will be objected that it is the privilege
of poets to lie, since the peculiar province of poetry is to charm3413 the spirits of the hearers,
while the very essence of truth is that things told be in reality exactly what they are said to
be.3414 Let us grant that it is a characteristic of poetry occasionally to conceal the truth. But
3410 “All the Greek-speaking world, and foreign lands as well.”
3411 Rhadamanthus was a son of Jove (or Vulcan) and Europa. Cf. Hom. Il. 14. 322; Od. 4. 564, 7. 323.
3412 [There can be no doubt (though the fact is not immediately apparent from the wording of the text), that
the spirit of this passage is ironical.—Bag.]
3413 Rather “cheat,” or “delude.” Mr. Charles Dudley Warner, essayist and novelist, says in an interesting
essay on the relation of fiction to life, that the object of fiction is to produce illusions, and the test of its art is its
power to produce such illusion.
3414 There is a temptation here to adopt the translation of Molz. “Truth lies in the fiction, however, when
what is told corresponds to reality.” Mr. Warner, in his lecture, goes on to say that the object of fiction is to reveal
what is,—not the base and sordid things only or peculiarly, but the best possibilities, and gives an exquisite ex-
position of the fact that the idealism of true fiction is simply the realism of the nobler characteristics and truths.
The truth is, that the object of fiction or poetry as art is to produce the image,—fill the whole personality with
a picture. This is only gained in its highest form when every detail exactly corresponds to truth or reality. The
function of fiction is not illusion, but realization. Its object is the reproduction of truth. Molz. makes Constantine
say that fiction is true when it corresponds to reality, though the forms be not historical or actual. This is a true
Of those who reject the Doctrines of Philosophers, as well as those of Scripture: and that we ought to believe the Poets in All Things, or disbelieve them in All.
1444
Of those who reject the Doctrines of Philosophers, as well as those of Scripture:…