It lies in the agent’s mind, or the disposition whence the volition springs, and whence its character is derived.
If God influence the mind so as to make it, in a given degree, to resemble his own moral nature; in that degree
would the choice made be morally good. But if passive power be not counteracted by such influence, (which
being gracious, God is not bound in equity to do.) in any given degree, the nature of things, the essence of truth;
connects, in a corresponding degree, the state of mind with the volition. 7. Hence it is plain, that moral influence,
as such, effects nothing certain; but always requires a previous state of mind, in order to insure a certainty of
good effect; and that previous state of mind is effected by no other possible means but a physical energy or
agency, producing assimilation. There must be a virtuous mind before a virtuous choice; the quality of the act
is derived from the agent. 8. One thing, which has been a source of much obscurity and confusion in reference
to moral agency, is the supposition that the mind is equally free, in all respects, when choosing good and when
choosing evil; in other words, that the one volition and the other becomes morally certain, form the same sort
of necessity. But this is not the real case. Indeed the necessity of connexion between the previous state of mind
and the corresponding volition, is the same; for it is, in each case, nothing else but the nature of things; but that
necessity which effects a state of mind previous to good volitions, is as different from the other necessity which
effects a state of mind previous to volitions morally evil, as light is from darkness. They proceed from opposite
quarters, and operate in contrary directions. A holy disposition is generated by decretive holy influence; the
other disposition (which ought not however to be called unholy) proceeds form the hypothetical nature of things.
Such a disposition, though no morally vicious, yet generates vice in union with free agency. 9. It is highly worthy
of remark, that though a good volition must proceed from a good heart, morally considered; yet a bad volition
does not, originally and necessarily, proceed from a morally bad heart. The reason is, that the one state of heart
proceeds form God., from his decretive holy will; the other proceeds form passive power, which is only a natural
evil, and not a moral. Besides, were the disposition which immediately precedes a bad volition necessarily, or
in a every case, evil, in a moral sense, either moral evil could have no place at all in the universe, no origin
whatever, or else it must be the same as passive power. But passive power is a contrast, not to the moral perfections
of God, but his natural; and has, when alone, no moral quality. And, seeing it belongs as a property to every
creature, as such, were it any thing morally evil, moral evil would be essential to the very being of every creature;
which is absurd. 10. Hence it is plain, that freedom is experienced in a higher sense or a greater degree, in bad
volitions, than in good ones in such a sense, and to such a degree, as to justify this mode of expression. That
man is necessitated to good, but free to evil. This however may need some explanatory qualification; for he is
not so necessitated to good, as not to be morally or hypothetically free; nor so free to evil as not to be subject to
a necessity of consequence. He who acts or chooses amiss without constraint, compulsion, or interfering voluntary
force in that act, notwithstanding his passive power, is properly a free agent; for in the moral quality of the act,
there is properly and strictly no will concerned but his own. But he who acts or chooses aright, is subject to a
physical, decretive necessity, as to his disposition and a physical concourse of divine energy in the natural act
of the will. He is indeed morally free, inasmuch as his volition might have been of a different, yea, of an opposite
moral quality, if the state of his mind had been different. Hence it is evident, that in a good will, choice, or act,
man is an agent in a less proper or secondary sense; but in a bad will, choice, or act, man is an agent, a moral
agent, a free agent, in the most proper and strict sense. And in the production of an act morally good two wills
are concerned, that of the agent, and the decretive will of God; in that of evil, only one, the agent’s own will. 11.
683
SECTION II. The Falseness and Inconsistence of that metaphysical notion…