Chapter 51.—63. Next, listen for a short time to the kind of way in which he has tried
to use, in his own behalf, the passages which I had advanced from the writings of the Apostle
Paul. "For you asserted," he says, "that the Apostle Paul finds fault with those who used to
say that they were of the Apostle Paul, saying, ‘Was Paul crucified for you? or were ye baptized
in the name of Paul?’2444 Wherefore, if they were in error, and would have perished had
they not been corrected, because they wished to be of Paul, what hope can there possibly be
for those who have wished to be of Donatus? For this is their sole object, that the origin,
and root, and head of him that is baptized should be none other than he by whom he is
623
baptized."2445 These words, and this confirmation from the writings of the apostle, he has
quoted from my epistle, and he has proposed to himself the task of refuting them. Go on
then, I beg of you, to see how he has fulfilled the task. For he says, "This assertion is mean-
ingless, and inflated, and childish, and foolish, and something very far from a true exposition
of our faith. For you would only be right in asserting this, if we were to say, We have been
baptized in the name of Donatus, or Donatus was crucified for us, or we have been baptized
in our own name. But since such things as this neither have been said nor are said by
us,—seeing that we follow the formula of the holy Trinity,—it is clear that you are mad to
bring such accusations against us. Or if you think that we have been baptized in the name
of Donatus, or in our own name, you are miserably deceived, and at the same time confess
in your sacrilege that you on your part defile your wretched selves in the name of Cæcilianus."
This is the answer which Petilianus has made to those arguments of mine, not supposing—or
rather making a noise that no one might suppose—that he has made no answer at all which
could bear in any way upon the question which is under discussion. For who could fail to
see that this witness of the apostle has been adduced by us with all the more propriety, in
that you do not say that you were baptized in the name of Donatus, or that Donatus was
crucified for you, and yet separate yourselves from the communion of the Catholic Church
out of respect to the party of Donatus; as also those whom Paul was rebuking certainly did
not say that they had been baptized in the name of Paul, or that Paul has been crucified for
them, and yet they were making a schism in the name of Paul. As therefore in their case,
for whom Christ, not Paul, was crucified, and who were baptized in the name of Christ, not
of Paul, and who yet said, "I am of Paul," the rebuke is used with all the more propriety,
"Was Paul crucified for you? or were ye baptized in the name of Paul?" to make them cling
to Him who was crucified for them, and in whose name they were baptized, and not be
guilty of division in the name of Paul; so in your case, also, the rebuke, Was Donatus crucified
for you? or were ye baptized in the name of Donatus? is used all the more appositely, because
you do not say, We were baptized in the name of Donatus, and yet desire to be of the party
2444 1 Cor. i. 13.
2445 See Book I. cc. 3, 4, 4, 5.
Chapter 51
1243
Chapter 51