Chapter 21.—24. But see, when he is reduced to straits in the argument, he again makes
an attack on me full of mist and wind, that the calm clearness of the truth may be obscured;
and through the extremity of his want he becomes full of resources, shown not in saying
what is true, but in unbought empty revilings. Hold fast, with the keenest attention and
utmost perseverance, what he ought to answer,—that is, where means may be found for
cleansing the conscience of the recipient when the stains in that of the giver are con-
606
cealed,—lest possibly the blast of his eloquence should wrest this from your hands, and you
in turn should be carried away by the dark tempest of his turgid discourse, so as wholly to
fail in seeing whence he has digressed, and to what point he should return; and see where
the man can wander, whilst he cannot stand in the matter which he has undertaken. For
see how much he says, through having nothing that he ought to say. He says "that I slide
in slippery places, but am held up; that I neither destroy nor confirm the objections that I
make; that I devise uncertain things in the place of certainty; that I do not permit my readers
to believe what is true, but cause them to look with increased suspicion on what is doubtful."
He says "that I have the accursed talents of the Academic philosopher Carneades."2374 He
endeavors to insinuate what the Academics think of the falseness or the falsehood of human
sensation, showing in this also that he is wholly without knowledge of what he says. He
declares that "it is said by them that snow is black, whereas it is white; and that silver is black;
and that a tower is round, or free from projections, when it is really angular; that an oar is
broken in the water, while it is whole."2375 And all this because, when he had said that "the
conscience of him that gives," or "of him that gives in holiness, is what we look for to cleanse
the conscience of the recipient," I said in reply, What if the conscience of the giver be hidden
from sight, and possibly be stained with guilt? Here you have his black snow, and black
silver, and his tower round instead of angular, and the oar in the water broken while yet
whole, in that I suggested a state of the case which might be conceived, and could not really
exist, that the conscience of the giver might be hidden from view, and possibly might be
stained with guilt!
25. Then he continues in the same strain, and cries out: "What is that what if? what is
that possibly? except the uncertain and wavering hesitation of one who doubts, of whom
your poet says’—
‘What if I now return to those who say, What if the sky should fall?’"2376
2374 Lactantius, Divin. Instit. Book V. c. xv., tells us of the talents of Carneades, recording that when he was
sent on an embassy to Rome by the Athenians, he spoke there first in defense of justice, and then on the following
day in opposition to it; and that he was in the habit of speaking with such force on either side, as to be able to
refute any arguments advanced by anybody else.
2375 Ter. Heaut. act. IV. scen. iii. vers. 41.
2376 Ter. Heaut. act. IV. scen. iii. vers. 41.
Chapter 21
1205
Chapter 21