It may be further observed, that certainly it is no better objection against our doctrine,
that it agrees, in some respects, with the doctrine of the ancient Stoic philosophers; than it
is against theirs, wherein they differ from us, that it agrees, in some respects, with the
opinion of the very worst of the heathen philosophers, the followers of Epicurus, the father
of atheism and licentiousness, and with the doctrine of the Sadducces and Jesuits.
I am not much concerned to know precisely, what the ancient Stoic philosophers held
concerning Fate, in order to determine what is truth; as though it were a sure way to be in
the right, to take good heed to differ from them. It seems, that they differed among them-
selves; and probably the doctrine of Fate, as maintained by most of them, was, in some re-
spects, erroneous. But whatever their doctrine was, if any of them held such a Fate, as is re-
pugnant to any liberty, consisting in our doing as we please, I utterly deny such a Fate. If
they held any such Fate, as is not consistent with the common and universal notions that
mankind have of liberty, activity, moral agency, virtue and vice; I disclaim any such thing,
and think I have demonstrated, that the scheme I maintain is no such scheme. If the Stoics,
by Fate, meant any thing of such a nature, as can be supposed to stand in the way of advantage
and benefit of in use of means and endeavours, or would make it less worth while for men
to desire and seek after any thing wherein their virtue and happiness consists; I hold no
doctrine that is clogged with any such inconvenience, any more than any other scheme
whatsoever; and by no means so much as the Arminian scheme of contingence; as has been
shown. If they held any such doctrine of universal fatality, as is inconsistent with any kind
of liberty, that is or can be any perfection, dignity, privilege, or benefit, or any thing desirable,
in any respect, for any intelligent creature, or indeed with any liberty that is possible or
conceivable; I embrace no such doctrine. If they held any such doctrine of Fate, as is incon-
sistent with the world being in all things subject to the disposal of an intelligent, wise agent,
that presides—not as the soul of the world, but—as the Sovereign Lord of the Universe,
governing all things by proper will, choice, and design, in the exercise of the most perfect
liberty conceivable, without subjection to any constraint, or being properly under the power
or influence of any thing before, above, or without himself; I wholly renounce any such
doctrine.
As to Mr. Hobbes maintaining the same doctrine concerning necessity; I confess, it
happens I never read Mr. Hobbes. Let his opinion be what it will, we need not reject all truth
which is demonstrated by clear evidence, merely because it was once held by some bad man.
This great truth, “that Jesus is the Son of God,” was not spoiled because it was once and
again proclaimed with a loud voice by the devil. If truth is so defiled, because it is spoken
by the mouth, or written by the pen, of some ill minded, mischievous man, that it must
never be received, we shall never know, when we hold any of the most precious and evident
truths by a sure tenure. And if Mr. Hobbes has made a bad use of this truth, that is to be
707
SECTION VI. Concerning that objection against the doctrine which has been…