ition, as it is not true, cannot be believed to be true, till saving faith be first complete.
Therefore the completeness of the act of saving faith will not make it take in a belief of this
proposition, nor will the strength or perfection of the act cause it to imply this. If a man, in
his first act of faith, has ever so full a conviction of God’s sufficiency and faithfulness, and
ever so strong and perfect a reliance on the divine testimony; all will have no tendency to
make him believe that this proposition, I am in a good estate, is true, until it is true; which
is not the fact, till the first act of faith is complete, and has made it true. A belief of divine
testimony, in the first act of faith, may be to an assignable degree of strength and perfection,
without believing the proposition, for there is no such divine testimony then extant, nor is
there any such truth extant, but in consequence of the first act of faith. Therefore, (as I said,)
saving faith may exist, with all that belongs to its essence, and that in the highest perfection,
without implying a belief of my own good estate. I do not say that it can exist without having
this immediate effect. But it is rather the effect of faith, than a part, branch, or ingredient of
faith. So I do not dispute whether a man’s doubting of his good estate, may be a consequence
of unbelief, and I doubt not but it is in those who are in a good estate; because, if men had
the exercise of faith in such a degree as they ought to have, it could not but be very sensible
and plain that they had it. But yet I think this doubting of one’s good estate, is entirely a
different thing from the sin of unbelief itself, and has nothing of the nature of unbelief in
it, i.e. if we take doubting one’s good estate in the sense in which I have before explained it,
viz. doubting whether I have such individual principles and acts in my soul. Take it in a
complex sense, and it may have the sin of unbelief in it; e.g. If, although I doubt not that I
have such and such qualifications, I yet doubt of those consequences. for which I have divine
testimony or promise; as when a person doubts not that he loves Christ, yet doubts whether
he shall receive a crown of life. The doubting of this consequence is properly the sin of unbe-
lief.
You say, dear Sir, ‘the Holy Ghost requires us to believe the reality of its works in us in
all its parts just as it is;’ and a little before, ‘the believer’s doubting whether or not he has
faith, is sinful; because it is belying the Holy Ghost, denying his work in him, so there is no
sin to which that doubting can so properly be reduced as unbelief.’
Here I would ask leave thus to express my thoughts, in a diversity from yours. I think,
if it be allowed to be sinful for a believer to doubt whether he has faith, that this doubting
is not the sin of unbelief on any such account as you mention, viz. as belying or denying
any testimony of the Holy Ghost. There is a difference between doubting of the being of
some work of the Holy Ghost, and denying the testimony of the Holy Ghost; as there is a
difference between doubting concerning some other works of God, and denying the testimony
of God. It is the work of God to give a man great natural abilities; and if we suppose that
God requires a man thus endowed to believe the reality of his work in all its parts just as it
is, and therefore, that it is sinful for him at all to doubt of his natural abilities being just as
227
CHAPTER XV. Arrival of David Brainerd at Northampton. His sickness and…