that is the Son’s the Father hath.” The words are, ‘The Father hath that which is the Son’s206,’
and so a carping critic will have no authority for finding in the contents of the word “all”
the ungeneracy of the Son, when it is said that the Son has all that the Father has, nor on
the other hand the generation of the Father, when all that is the Son’s is to be observed in
the Father. For the Son has all the things of the Father; but He is not Father: and again, all
the things of the Son are to be observed in the Father, but He is not a Son.
If, then, all that is the Father’s is in the Only-begotten, and He is in the Father, and the
Fatherhood is not dissociated from the ‘not having been generated,’ I for my part cannot
see what there is to think of in connexion with the Father, by Himself, that is parted by any
interval so as to precede our apprehension of the Son. Therefore we may boldly encounter
the difficulties started in that quibbling syllogism; we may despise it as a mere scare to
frighten children, and still assert that God is Holy, and Immortal, and Father, and Ungenerate,
and Everlasting, and everything all at once; and that, if it could be supposed possible that
you could withhold one of these attributes which devotion assigns to Him, all would be
destroyed along with that one. Nothing, therefore, in Him is older or younger; else He would
be found to be older or younger than Himself. If God is not all His attributes always, but
something in Him is, and something else only becoming, following some order of sequence
(we must remember God is not a compound; whatever He is is the whole of Him), and if
according to this heresy He is first Ungenerate and afterwards becomes Father, then, seeing
91
that we cannot think of Him in connexion with a heaping together of qualities, there is no
alternative but that the whole of Him must be both older and younger than the whole of
Him, the former by virtue of His Ungeneracy, the latter by virtue of His Fatherhood. But
if, as the prophet says of God207, He “is the same,” it is idle to say that before He begat He
was not Himself Ungenerate; we cannot find either of these names, the Father and the Un-
generate One, parted from the other; the two ideas rise together, suggested by each other,
in the thoughts of the devout reasoner. God is Father from everlasting, and everlasting
Father, and every other term that devotion assigns to Him is given in a like sense, the men-
suration and the flow of time having no place, as we have said, in the Eternal.
Let us now see the remaining results of his expertness in dealing with words; results,
which he himself truly says, are at once ridiculous and lamentable. Truly one must laugh
outright at what he says, if a deep lament for the error that steeps his soul were not more
fitting. Whereas Father, as we teach, includes, according to one of its meanings, the idea of
the Ungenerate, he transfers the full signification of the word Father to that of the Ungenerate,
and declares “If Father is the same as Ungenerate, it is allowable for us to drop it, and use
206 John xvi. 15. Oehler conjectures these words (῎Εχει ὁ πατὴρ) are to be repeated; and thus obtains a good
sense, which the common reading, ὁ πατὴρ εἶπον, does not give.
207 Psalm cii. 27.
173
Several ways of controverting his quibbling syllogisms.