Chapter VIII.
The likeness of the Son to the Father being proved, it is not hard to prove the Son’s
eternity, though, indeed, this may be established on the authority of the Prophet Isaiah and
St. John the Evangelist, by which authority the heretical leaders are shown to be refuted.
54. It is plain, therefore, that the Son is not unlike the Father, and so we may confess
the more readily that He is also eternal, seeing that He Who is like the Eternal must needs
be eternal. But if we say that the Father is eternal, and yet deny this of the Son, we say that
the Son is unlike the Father, for the temporal differeth from the eternal. The Prophet pro-
claims Him eternal, and the Apostle proclaims Him eternal; the Testaments, Old and New
alike, are full of witness to the Son’s eternity.
55. Let us take them, then, in their order. In the Old Testament—to cite one out of a
multitude of testimonies—it is written: “Before Me hath there been no other God, and after
Me shall there be none.”995 I will not comment on this place, but ask thee straight: “Who
speaks these words,—the Father or the Son?” Whichever of the two thou sayest, thou wilt
find thyself convinced, or, if a believer, instructed. Who, then, speaks these words, the
Father or the Son? If it is the Son, He says, “Before Me hath there been no other God;” if
the Father, He says, “After Me shall there be none.” The One hath none before Him, the
Other none that comes after; as the Father is known in the Son, so also is the Son known in
the Father, for whensoever you speak of the Father, you speak also by implication of His
Son, seeing that none is his own father; and when you name the Son, you do also acknowledge
His Father, inasmuch as none can be his own son. And so neither can the Son exist without
the Father, nor the Father without the Son.996 The Father, therefore, is eternal, and the Son
also eternal.
56. “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was
God. The same was in the beginning with God.”997 “Was,” mark you, “with God.”
“Was”—see, we have “was” four times over. Where did the blasphemer find it written that
He “was not.” Again, John, in another passage—in his Epistle—speaketh of “That which
was in the beginning.”998 The extension of the “was” is infinite. Conceive any length of time
you will, yet still the Son “was.”999
995 Is. xliii. 10.
996 This holds good also of human fatherhood and sonship. The terms of a relation involve each the existence
of the other—no father, no son, and equally, no son, no father.
997 S. John i. 1 f. St. Ambrose notices especially the quadruple “was” as unmistakably signifying the Son’s
eternity. We may also notice the climax “The Word was in the beginning.…was with God.…was God.”
998 1 John i. 1.
999 Hurter cites similar passages from the Fathers of the Church, proving the Son’s pre-existence and eternity.
“What is the force of those words ‘In the beginning’? Centuries are o’erleaped, ages are swallowed up. Take any
beginning you will, yet you cannot include it in time, for that, whence time is reckoned, already was.”—Hilary.
Chapter VIII. The likeness of the Son to the Father being proved, it is not hard to prove the Son's eternity, though, indeed, this may be established on the authority of the Prophet Isaiah and St. John the Evangelist, by which authority the heretical leaders are shown to be refuted.
462
Chapter VIII. The likeness of the Son to the Father being proved, it is…