OBJECT. XII.
The Lord’s supper has a proper tendency to promote men’s conversion, being an affecting
representation of the greatest and most important things of God’s word: it has a proper
tendency to awaken and humble sinners; here being a discovery of the terrible anger of God
for sin, by the infliction of the curse upon Christ, when sin was imputed to him; and the
representation here made of the dying love of Christ has a tendency to draw the hearts of
sinners from sin to God, &c.
Answ. Unless it be an evident truth, that what the Lord’s supper may have tendency to
promote, the same it was appointed to promote, nothing follows from this argument. If the
argument affords any consequence, the consequence is built on the tendency of the Lord’s
supper. And if the consequence be good and strong on this foundation, as drawn from such
premises, then wherever the premises hold, the consequence holds; otherwise it must appear,
that the premises and consequence are not connected. And now let us see how it is in fact.
Do not scandalous persons need to have these very effects wrought in their hearts which
have been mentioned? Yes, surely; they need them in a special manner: they need to be
awakened; they need to have an affecting discovery of that terrible wrath of God against sin,
which was manifested in a peculiar manner by the terrible effects of God’s wrath in the
sufferings of his own incarnate Son. Gross sinners need this in some respect more than
others. They need to have their hearts broken by an affecting view of the great and important
things of God’s word. They need especially to fly to Christ for refuge, and therefore need to
have their hearts drawn. And seeing the Lord’s supper has so great a tendency to promote
these things, if the consequence from the tendency of the Lord’s supper, as inferring the end
of its appointment, be good, then it must be a consequence also well inferred, that the Lord’s
supper was appointed for the reclaiming and bringing to repentance scandalous persons.
To turn this off, by saying, Scandalous persons are expressly forbid, is but giving up the
argument, and begging the question. It is giving up the argument; since it allows the con-
sequence not to be good. For it allows, that notwithstanding the proper tendency of the Lord’s
supper to promote a design, yet it may be the Lord’s supper was not appointed with a view
to promote that end.—And it is a begging the question; since it supposes, that unconverted
men are not evidently forbidden, as well as scandalous persons; which is the thing in contro-
versy. If they be evidently forbid, that is as much to reasonable creatures (who need nothing
but good evidence) as if they were expressly forbidden.—To say here, that the Lord’s supper
is a converting ordinance only to orderly members, and that there is another ordinance ap-
pointed for bringing scandalous persons to repentance, this is no solution of the difficulty;
but is only another instance of yielding up the argument, and begging the question. For it
plainly concedes, that the tendency of an ordinance does not prove it appointed to all the
ends, which it seems to have a tendency to promote; and also supposes, that there is not any
OBJ. XII. Tendency of the Lord's supper.
1858
OBJ. XII. Tendency of the Lord's supper.