objections to its contents and his doubts as to its apostolicity caused him to contemplate such a possibility not
without pleasure (see the next chapter, note 1). In chapter 18, above, he speaks of it as the “so-called” Apocalypse
of John, but in other places he repeats many testimonies in favor of its authenticity (see the next note), and only
in chapter 39 does he state clearly his own opinion in the matter, which even there he does not press as a fixed
conviction. The reason for the doubts of the book’s genuineness on the part of Eusebius and so many others lay
evidently most of all in objections to the contents of the book, which seemed to favor chiliasm, and had been
greatly abused for the advancement of the crassest chiliastic views. Many, like Dionysius of Alexandria were no
doubt influenced also by the idea that it was impossible that the Gospel and the Apocalypse could be the works
of one author, and they preferred to sacrifice the latter rather than the former. The book has found objectors in
almost every age of the Church, but has continued to hold its place in the canon (its position was never disturbed
in the Western Church, and only for some two or three centuries after Eusebius in parts of the Eastern Church)
as an authentic work of the apostle John. The Tübingen school exalted the Apocalypse to the honorable position
of one of the five genuine monuments of the apostolic age, and from it as a basis conducted their attacks upon
the other Johannine writings. The more modern critical school is doubtful about it as well as the rest of the Jo-
hannine literature, and the latest theory makes the Apocalypse a Jewish document in a Christianized form (see
above, chap. 18, note 1). Compare especially Holtzmann’s Einleitung, p. 411–413, and Weiss’ Einleitung, p. 93.
777 See Bk. VII. chap. 25, where Eusebius quotes a lengthy discussion of the Apocalypse by Dionysius of Al-
exandria. He also cites opinions favorable to the authenticity of the Apocalypse from Justin (in IV. 18, below),
Theophilus (IV. 24), Irenæus (V. 8), and Origen (VI. 25), but such scattered testimonies can hardly be regarded
as the fulfillment of the definite promise which he makes in this passage.
320
The Order of the Gospels.