Spirit the recipients attain the dignity of adoption. Again, in the passage, “No one knoweth
the things of a man save the spirit of man which is in him,” if “man” is used of the essence,
and “spirit” likewise, it will follow from the phrase that the man is maintained to be of two
essences. Again, I know not how he who says that “the letter killeth, but the Spirit giveth
life,” sets “essence” in opposition to “letter”; nor, again, how this writer imagines that when
Paul says that we ought “through the Spirit” to destroy “the deeds of the body,” he is directing
the signification of “spirit” to express “essence”; while as for “living in the Spirit,” and
“walking in the Spirit,” this would be quite unintelligible if the sense of the word “Spirit”
referred to “essence.” For in what else than in essence do all we who are alive partake of
life?—thus when the Apostle is laying down advice for us on this matter that we should “live
in essence,” it is as though he said “partake of life by means of yourselves, and not by means
of others.” If then it is not possible that this sense can be adopted in any passage, how can
Eunomius here once more imitate the interpreters of dreams, and bid us to take “spirit” for
“essence,” to the end that he may arrive in due syllogistic form at his conclusion that the
word “Lord” is applied to the essence?—for if “spirit” is “essence” (he argues), and “the Lord
is Spirit,” the “Lord” is clearly found to be “essence.” How incontestable is the force of this
attempt! How can we evade or resolve this irrefragable necessity of demonstration? The
word “Lord,” he says, is spoken of the essence. How does he maintain it? Because the Apostle
192
says, “The Lord is the Spirit.” Well, what has this to do with essence? He gives us the further
instruction that “spirit” is put for “essence.” These are the arts of his demonstrative method!
These are the results of his Aristotelian science! This is why, in your view, we are so much
to be pitied, who are uninitiated in this wisdom! and you of course are to be deemed happy,
who track out the truth by a method like this—that the Apostle’s meaning was such that we
are to suppose “the Spirit” was put by him for the Essence of the Only-begotten!
Then how will you make it fit with what follows? For when Paul says, “Now the Lord
is the Spirit,” he goes on to say, “and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty.” If then
“the Lord is the Spirit,” and “Spirit” means “essence,” what are we to understand by “the
essence of the essence”? He speaks again of another Spirit of the Lord Who is the Spirit,—that
is to say, according to your interpretation, of another essence. Therefore in your view the
Apostle, when he writes expressly of “the Lord the Spirit,” and of “the Spirit of the Lord,”
means nothing else than an essence of an essence. Well, let Eunomius make what he likes
of that which is written; what we understand of the matter is as follows. The Scripture,
“given by inspiration of God,” as the Apostle calls it, is the Scripture of the Holy Spirit, and
its intention is the profit of men. For “every scripture,” he says, “is given by inspiration of
God and is profitable”; and the profit is varied and multiform, as the Apostle says—“for
doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness818.” Such a boon as
818 2 Tim. iii. 16.
368
The seventh book shows from various statements made to the Corinthians and…