Donatus had resigned his proconsulship. Augustin writes [Ep. cxii.] at the end of 409
or beginning of 410 A.D., to express his regrets at not meeting him on his visit to Tibilis;
his retirement would now give leisure for a larger development in graces, and would lead
him to esteem the superiority of eternal things. He praises him for his official worth, which
indeed was in everybody’s mouth, but he urges him not to defer to that popularity, but to
seek the higher approbation. After reminding him of the duty of Christian progress, he asks
for a reply and an exhortation to be addressed to all his dependents at Sinitis and Hippo to
return to the Church. Greetings are sent to his father, whom the son had been instrumental
in converting to the faith.
Petilian of Constantina had written a treatise, de unico baptismo, which Constantinus
had come into possession of through some Donatist presbyter, and then gave it to Augustin
while they were in the country, imploring him to answer it. He did so, c. 410, in the book
bearing the same title. He scorns those who desire secrecy in such matters; when the deeds
are public let the discussion be. Petilian claims that the only true baptism is theirs: and
therefore it is not repeated by the sacrilegious theorists. Yes, replies Augustin, baptism is
indeed one, but it is Christ’s, not yours; yours is only a repetition of the rite. We correct
what is yours and recognize what is Christ’s. Therefore we do not repeat it. So Christ cor-
rected what was evil and recognized what was good among the Jews. So Paul exposed the
sin of the heathen world but acknowledged what truth it had. Moreover you perform the
ceremony, but it is to destruction: there is no real advantage in baptism outside of the
Church. Petilian pleads for rebaptism because Paul rebaptized John’s disciples; but, says
Augustin, that is to declare John a heretic. These are two different things, as indeed Petilian
himself suggests, some might say, and then gives two irrelevant passages, Matt. xii. 30, and
vii. 21–23, as if the Catholics had no fellowship with Christ and were not recognized by
Him. Augustin, after considering the import of these passages, avers the readiness of the
Church to recognize the baptism of Christ as administered by Donatists when they return
to the Church; for to deny Christ’s baptism because it is administered by heretics, is to say
Christ Himself should be denied, when even demons confess Him. There is a belief in God
outside of the Church; the devils believe in Him outside of the Church. So there is one
baptism of Christ which may exist also outside of the Church. Petilian’s declaration that
true baptism is where the true faith is, Augustin disproves by citing the case of the unbelieving
and schismatic, yet baptized Corinthians. So all the ages of the kingdom bear witness to a
like state of things. The action of Agrippinus and Cyprian on the one side, and of Stephen
on the other, as to rebaptism is reviewed; differing in this, they yet maintained unity, espe-
cially Cyprian. Further, if the contact of evil men within the fellowship really defiles the
good, then the Church perished in Cyprian’s time; where could Donatus then have been
spiritually born? If there is no such pollution, then there is no occasion to rage for separation.
The origin of the schism is then denied from documentary testimony, and the charges de-
673
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.