Chapter III
Eusebius’ Church
History.
§1.
Date of its Composition
The
work with which we are especially concerned at this time is the
Church History
, the original Greek of which is still extant in
numerous
mss.
It consists of ten books, to
which is added in most of the
mss.
the shorter
form of the
Martyrs of Palestine
(see above, p. 29). The date of
the work can be determined with considerable exactness. It closes with
a eulogy of Constantine and his son Crispus; and since the latter was
put to death by his father in the summer of 326, the
History
must have been completed before that time. On the other hand, in the
same chapter Eusebius refers to the defeat of Licinius, which took
place in the year 323
a.d.
This gives a fixed
terminus a quo
. It is not quite certain from Eusebius’
words whether the death of Licinius had already taken place at the time
he wrote, but it seems probable that it had, and if so, the completion
of the work must be put as late as the summer of 324. On the other
hand, not the slightest reference is made to the Council of Nicæa,
which met in the summer of 325; and still further the tenth book is
dedicated to Paulinus, at one time bishop of Tyre and afterward bishop
of Antioch (see Euseb.
Contra Marc
. I. 4, and Philost.
H.
E
. III. 15), who was already dead in the summer of 325: for at the
Nicene Council, Zeno appears as bishop of Tyre, and Eustathius as
bishop of Antioch (see for further particulars Lightfoot, p. 322). We
are thus led to place the completion of the
History
in the year
324, or, to give the widest possible limits, between the latter part of
323 and the early part of 325
a.d.
But the question has been raised
whether the earlier books may not have been composed some years before
this. Lightfoot (following Westcott) supposes that the first nine books
were completed not long after the edict of Milan and before the
outbreak of the quarrel between Constantine and Licinius in 314. There
is considerable to be said in favor of this theory. The language used
in the dedication of the tenth book seems to imply that the nine books
had been completed some time before, and that the tenth is added as a
sort of postscript. The close of the ninth book strengthens that
conclusion. Moreover, it would seem from the last sentences of that
book that Constantine and Licinius were in perfect harmony at the time
it was written, a state of affairs which did not exist after 314. On
the other hand, it must be noticed that in Book IX. chap. 9
Licinius’ “madness” is twice referred to as having
“not yet” seized him (in §1
οὔπω
μανέντος
τοτε
, and in
§12
οὔπω
τότε ἐφ᾽ ἣν
ὕστερον
ἐκπέπτωκε
μανίαν, τὴν
δι€νοιαν
ἐκτραπείς
). It is necessary either to interpret both these clauses as
later insertions (possibly by Eusebius’ own hand at the time when
he added the tenth book; cf. also p. 30, above), or to throw the
composition of the ninth book down to the year 319 or later. It is
difficult to decide between these alternatives, but I am inclined on
the whole to think that Westcott’s theory is probably correct,
and that the two clauses can best be interpreted as later insertions.
The very nature of his
History
would at any rate lead us to
think that Eusebius spent some years in the composition of it, and that
the earlier books, if not published, were at least completed long
before the issue of the ten books as a whole. The
Chronicle
is
referred to as already written in I. 1; the
Eclogæ Proph
.
(? see below, p. 85) in I. 2 and 6; the
Collection of Ancient
Martyrdoms
in IV. 15, V. preface, 4, and 22; the
Defense of
Origen
in VI. 23, 33, and 36; the
Life of Pamphilus
in VI.
32, VII. 32, and VIII. 13. In VIII. 13 Eusebius speaks also of his
intention of relating the sufferings of the martyrs in another work
(but see above, p. 30).