sinners, or that He punishes innocent souls and seeing that, on the other hand, it is not
lawful for us to deny that nothing else than perdition is the doom of the souls, even of little
children, which have departed from the body without the sacrament of Christ, tell me, I
implore you, where anything can be found to support the opinion that souls are not all de-
rived from that one soul of the first man, but are each created separately for each individual,
as Adam’s soul was made for him.
Chap. V.
11. As for some other objections which are advanced against this opinion, I think that
I could easily dispose of them. For example, some think that they urge a conclusive argument
against this opinion when they ask, how God finished all His works an the sixth day and
rested on the seventh day,2731 if He is still creating new souls. If we meet them with the
527
quotation from the gospel (given by you in the letter to Marcellinus already mentioned),
“My Father worketh hitherto,” they answer that He “worketh” in maintaining those natures
which He has created, not in creating new natures; otherwise, this statement would contradict
the words of Scripture in Genesis, where it is most plainly declared that God finished all
His works. Moreover, the words of Scripture, that He rested, are unquestionably to be un-
derstood of His resting from creating new creatures, not from governing those which He
had created; for at that time He made things which previously did not exist, and from
making these He rested because He had finished all the creatures which before they existed
He saw necessary to be created, so that thenceforward He did not create and make things
which previously did not exist, but made and fashioned out of things already existing
whatever He did make. Thus the statements, “He rested from His works,” and, “He worketh
hitherto,” are both true, for the gospel could not contradict Genesis.
12. When, however, these things are brought forward by persons who advance them as
conclusive against the opinion that God now creates new souls as He created the soul of the
first man, and who hold either that He forms them from that one soul which existed before
He rested from creation, or that He now sends them forth into bodies from some reservoir
or storehouse of souls which He then created, it is easy to turn aside their argument by an-
swering, that even in the six days God formed many things out of those natures which He
had already created, as, for example, the birds and fishes were formed from the waters, and
the trees, the grass, and the animals from the earth, and yet it is undeniable that He was then
making things which did not exist before. For there existed previously no bird, no fish, no
tree, no animal, and it is clearly understood that He rested from creating those things which
previously were not, and were then created, that is to say, He ceased in this sense, that, after
that, nothing was made by Him which did not already exist. But if, rejecting the opinions
of all who believe either that God sends forth into men souls existing already in some incom-
2731 Gen. ii. 2.
1121
To Jerome