In June last, I received a letter from you, dated January 22, 1757, with ‘Mr. Anderson’s
Complaint verified,’ and ‘Objections to the Essays 68 examined.’ For these things, I now return
my hearty thanks.
The conduct of the vindicator of the ‘Essays,’ from objections made against them, seems
to be very odd. Many things are produced from Calvin, and several Calvinistic writers, to
defend what is not objected against. His book is almost wholly taken up about that which
is nothing to the purpose; perhaps only to amuse and blind the common people. According
to your proposal, I have drawn up something, stating the difference between my hypothesis,
and that of the Essays; which I have sent to you, to be printed in Scotland, if it be thought
best; or to be disposed of as you think proper. Essays on the principles of Morality and
Natural Religion, by Lord Kaimes 69 I have written it in a letter to you; and if it be published,
it may be as ‘A letter from me to a minister in Scotland.’ Lord Kaimes’s notion of God’s
deceiving mankind, by a kind of invincible or natural instinct or feeling, leading them to
suppose, that they have a liberty of contingence and self-determination of will, in order to
make them believe themselves and others worthy to be blamed or praised for what they do,
is a strange notion indeed; and it is hard for me to conjecture, what his views could be, in
publishing such things to the world.
However, by what I have heard, some others seem to be so far of the same mind, that
they think, that if it be really true, that there is no self-determining power in the will, as
opposed to any such moral necessity, as I speak of, consisting in a certain connexion between
motives and volitions, it is of a mischievous tendency to say any thing of it; and that it is
best that the truth in this matter should not be known by any means. I cannot but be of an
extremely different mind. On the contrary, I think that the notion of liberty, consisting in
a contingent self-determination of the will, as necessary to the morality of men’s dispositions
and actions, is almost inconceivably pernicious; and that the contrary truth is one of the
most important truths of moral philosophy, that ever was discussed, and most necessary to
be known; and that for want of it, those schemes of morality and religion, which are a kind
of infidel schemes, entirely diverse from the virtue and religion of the Bible, and wholly in-
consistent with, and subversive of, the main things belonging to the gospel scheme, have so
vastly and so long prevailed, and have stood in such strength. And I think, whoever imagines
that he, or any body else, shall ever see the doctrines of grace effectually maintained against
these adversaries, till the truth in this matter be settled, imagines a vain thing. For, allow
these adversaries what they maintain in this point, and I think they have strict demonstration
against us. And not only have these errors a most pernicious influence, in the public religious
controversies that are maintained in the world; but such sort of notions have a more fatal
68 Essays on the principles of Morality and Natural Religion, by Lord Kaimes
69 See the letter in Vol.1. pp. 8.
357
CHAPTER XXIII. Sickness of Mr. Edwards. “God's Last End in Creation.” “Nature…