Chapter XII.
A fuller account of the Errors of Photinus, Apollinaris and Nestorius.
[32.] Here, possibly, I may be asked for some account of the above mentioned heresies;
those, namely, of Nestorius, Apollinaris, and Photinus. This, indeed, does not belong to the
matter in hand: for our object is not to enlarge upon the errors of individuals, but to produce
instances of a few, in whom the applicability of Moses’ words may be evidently and clearly
seen; that is to say, that if at any time some Master in the Church, himself also a prophet in
interpreting the mysteries of the prophets, should attempt to introduce some novel doctrine
into the Church of God, Divine Providence permits this to happen in order to try us. It will
be useful, therefore, by way of digression, to give a brief account of the opinions of the above-
named heretics, Photinus, Apollinaris, Nestorius.
[33.] The heresy of Photinus, then, is as follows: He says that God is singular and sole,
and is to be regarded as the Jews regarded Him. He denies the completeness of the Trinity,
and does not believe that there is any Person of God the Word, or any Person of the Holy
Ghost. Christ he affirms to be a mere man, whose original was from Mary. Hence he insists
with the utmost obstinacy that we are to render worship only to the Person of God the
Father, and that we are to honour Christ as man only. This is the doctrine of Photinus.
140
[34.] Apollinaris, affecting to agree with the Church as to the unity of the Trinity, though
not this even with entire soundness of belief,61 as to the Incarnation of the Lord, blasphemes
openly. For he says that the flesh of our Saviour was either altogether devoid of a human
soul, or, at all events, was devoid of a rational soul. Moreover, he says that this same flesh
of the Lord was not received from the flesh of the holy Virgin Mary, but came down from
heaven into the Virgin; and, ever wavering and undecided, he preaches one while that it
was co-eternal with God the Word, another that it was made of the divine nature of the
Word. For, denying that there are two substances in Christ, one divine, the other human,
one from the Father, the other from his mother, he holds that the very nature of the Word
was divided, as though one part of it remained in God, the other was converted into flesh:
so that whereas the truth says that of two substances there is one Christ, he affirms, contrary
to the truth, that of the one divinity of Christ there are become two substances. This, then,
is the doctrine of Apollinaris.
[35.] Nestorius, whose disease is of an opposite kind, while pretending that he holds
two distinct substances in Christ, brings in of a sudden two Persons, and with unheard of
wickedness would have two sons of God, two Christs,—one, God, the other, man, one, be-
gotten of his Father, the other, born of his mother. For which reason he maintains that Saint
Mary ought to be called, not Theotocos (the mother of God), but Christotocos (the mother
61 “Et hoc ipsum non plena fidei sanitate.”—The Cambridge Ed., 1687, with Baluzius’s notes appended, reads,
“et hoc ipsum plena fidei sanctitate.”
Chapter XII. A fuller account of the Errors of Photinus, Apollinaris and Nestorius.
322
Chapter XII. A fuller account of the Errors of Photinus, Apollinaris and…