Proof
that the Divinity of the Saviour is Impassible.
1. Alike by the divine Scripture
and by the holy Fathers assembled at Nicæa we have been taught to
confess that the Son is of one substance with God the Father. The
impassibility of the Father is also taught by the nature and proclaimed
by the divine Scripture. We shall then further confess the Son to be
impassible, for this definition is enforced by the identity of
substance. Whenever then we hear the divine Scripture proclaiming the
cross and the death of the Master Christ we attribute the passion to
the flesh, for in no wise is the Godhead, being by nature impassible,
capable of suffering.
2. “All things that the
Father hath are mine”
1597
says the Master
Christ, and one out of all is impassibility. If therefore as God He is
impassible, He suffered as man. For the divine nature does not undergo
suffering.
3. The Lord said “the
bread which I will give is my flesh which I will give for the life of
the world,”
1598
and again
“I am the good shepherd and know my sheep and am known of
mine…and I lay down my life for the sheep.”
1599
So body and soul are both given by the
good shepherd for the sheep who have soul and body.
4. The nature of men is
compounded of body and soul. But it sinned and stood in need of a
sacrifice free from every spot. So the Creator took a body and a soul,
and keeping them clean from the stains of sin for men’s bodies
gave His body and for their souls His soul. If this is true, and true
it is, for these are words of truth itself, then wild and blasphemous
are they who ascribe passion to the divine nature.
5. The blessed Paul called the
Christ “the first born of the dead;”
1600
and I suppose the first born has the same
nature as they of whom He is called first born. As man then He is first
born of the dead, for He first destroyed the pangs of death and gave to
all the sweet hope of another life. As He rose so He suffered. As man
then He suffered but as awful God He remained impassible.
6. The divine Apostle calls our
Saviour Christ “the firstfruits of them that slept,”
1601
but the firstfruits are related to the whole
whereof they are firstfruits. He is not therefore called firstfruits as
God, for what relationship is there between Godhead and manhood? The
former is an immortal nature, the latter mortal. Such is the nature of
them that sleep, of whom Christ is called firstfruits. To this nature
belong death and resurrection, and in its resurrection we have a proof
of the general resurrection.
7. When the Master Christ wished
to persuade the doubting Apostles that He had destroyed death and
risen, He shewed them parts of His body, His side, His hands, His feet
and the marks of the passion preserved therein. This body then rose,
and this, I ween, was shown to the disbelievers. What rose is what was
buried, and what was buried is what had died, and what had died is of
course what was nailed to the cross. So the divine nature united to the
body remained impassible.
8. They who describe the flesh
of the Lord as giver of life make life itself mortal by their words.
They ought to have seen that it was giver of life through the life
united to it. But if according to their argument the life is mortal,
how could the flesh being itself by nature mortal, and made life-giving
through the life, remain life-giving?
9. God the Word is by nature
immortal, and the flesh by nature mortal, but after the passion by
union with the Word the flesh itself became immortal. How then is it
not absurd to say that the giver of such immortality shared
death?
10. They who maintain that God the Word suffered in the flesh
should be asked the meaning of what they say, and should they have the
hardihood to reply that when the body was pierced with nails the divine
nature was sensible of pain, let them learn that the divine nature did
not fill the part of a soul. God the Word had assumed a soul with the
body. Should they reject this argument as blasphemous, and should they
assert that the flesh suffered by nature, and that God the Word made
the passion His own as of His own flesh, let them not propound puzzling
and murky phrases, but let them clearly propound the meaning of the ill
sounding phrase. They will have all those who wish to follow the divine
Scripture as their supporters in this interpretation.
11. The divine Peter in his
Catholic Epistle says that Christ suffered in the flesh.
1602
But he who hears that Christ suffered does
not understand God the Word incorporeal, but incarnate. The name of
Christ indicates both natures; but the word “flesh”
connected with the passion signifies not that both, but that one of the
two, suffered. For he that hears that Christ suffered in the flesh
thinks of Him as impassible in that He was God, and attributes the
passion to the flesh alone. For just as when we hear him saying that
God had sworn to David of the fruit of his loins according to the flesh
to raise up the Christ, we do not say that God the Word derived His
origin from David, but that the flesh which God the Word took was akin
to David, so must he who hears that Christ suffered in the flesh,
recognise that the passion belongs to the flesh, and confess the
impassibility of the Godhead.
12. When on the cross the Lord
Christ said, “Father into Thy hands I commend my spirit,”
1603
this spirit is said by the Arians and the
Eunomians to be the Godhead of the only-begotten, for they hold that
the body which He took was without a soul, but the heralds of the truth
say that the soul was so called and they base their opinion on the
following passages. The right wise Evangelist immediately adds
“And having said thus He gave up the ghost.”
1604
So says Luke, and the blessed Mark
similarly adds “He gave up the ghost.”
1605
The divine Matthew writes, “yielded up
the Ghost,”
1606
and the divine
John, “gave up the Ghost.”
1607
All speak according to the usage of men, for we are accustomed to use
all these expressions about those who die; none of them conveys any
meaning of Godhead, but they all signify the soul, and if any one were
to receive the Arian sense of the passage none the less even thus will
it shew the immortality of the divine nature. For Christ commended it
to the Father. He did not yield it to death. If then they that deny the
assumption of the soul, and maintain God the Word to be a creature, and
assert that He was in the body in place of a soul, deny that He was
delivered to death, how can they obtain pardon who while they confess
one substance of the Trinity, and leave the soul in its own
immortality, impudently dare to say that God the Word of one substance
with the Father tasted death?
13. If Christ is both God and
man, as the divine Scripture teaches, and the illustrious Fathers
persistently preached, then He suffered as man, but as God remained
impassible.
14. If they acknowledge the
assumption of the flesh, and declare it to be passible before the
resurrection, and preach that the nature of the Godhead is impassible,
why, leaving the passible nature, do they attribute the passion to the
impassible?
15. If our Lord and Saviour
nailed the handwriting to the cross, as says the divine Apostle,
1608
He then nailed the body, for on his body
every man like letters marks the prints of his sins, wherefore on
behalf of sinners He gave up the body that was free from all
sin.
16. When we say that the body or
the flesh or the manhood suffered, we do not separate the divine
nature, for as it was united to one hungering, thirsting, aweary, even
asleep, and undergoing the passion, itself affected by none of these
but permitting the human nature to be affected in its own way, so it
was conjoined to it even when crucified, and permitted the completion
of the passion, that by the passion it might destroy death; not indeed
receiving pain from the passion, but making the passion its own, as of
its own temple, and of the flesh united to it, on account of which
flesh also the faithful are called members of Christ, and He Himself is
styled the head of them that believed.
1597
John xvi. 15
1598
John vi. 51
1599
John x. 14,
15
1600
Coloss. i. 18
1601
1 Cor. xv. 20
1602
1 Pet. i. 1
1603
Luke xxiii.
46
1604
Luke xxiii.
46
1605
Mark xv. 39
1606
Matt. xxvii.
50
1607
John xix. 30
1608
Col. ii. 14