Chapter
XI
I shall
here insert the letter respecting the faith, written by Eusebius,
bishop of Cæsarea, as it describes the effrontery of the Arians,
who not only despise our fathers, but reject their own: it contains a
convincing proof of their madness. They certainly honour Eusebius,
because he adopted their sentiments, but yet they openly contradict his
writings. He wrote this epistle to some of the Arians, who were
accusing him, it seems, of treachery. The letter itself explains the
writer’s object.
Epistle of Eusebius, Bishop of
Cæsarea, which he wrote from Nicæa when the great Council was
assembled.
“
You
will have probably learnt from other sources what was
decided respecting the faith of the church at the general council of
Nicæa, for the fame of great transactions generally outruns the
accurate account of them: but lest rumours not in strict accordance
with the truth should reach you, I think it necessary to send to you,
first, the formulary of faith originally proposed by us, and, next, the
second, published with additions made to our terms. The following is
our formulary, which was read in the presence of our most pious
emperor, and declared to be couched in right and proper
language.
The Faith put forth by
us.
“‘
As
in our first catechetical instruction, and at the time
of our baptism, we received from the bishops who were before us and as
we have learnt from the Holy Scriptures, and, alike as presbyters, and
as bishops, were wont to believe and teach; so we now believe and thus
declare our faith. It is as follows:—
“‘We believe in one
God, Father Almighty, the Maker of all things, visible and invisible;
and in one Lord Jesus Christ, the Word of God, God of God, Light of
Light, Life of Life, Only-begotten Son, First-born of every creature,
begotten of the Father before all worlds; by Whom all things were made;
Who for our salvation was incarnate, and lived among men
365
. He suffered and rose again the third day,
and ascended to the Father; and He will come again in glory to judge
the quick and the dead. We also believe in one Holy Ghost.
“‘We believe in the
being and continual existence of each of these; that the Father is in
truth the Father; the Son in truth the Son; the Holy Ghost in truth the
Holy Ghost; as our Lord, when sending out His disciples to preach the
Gospel, said, ‘
Go forth and teach all nations, baptizing them
into the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy
Ghost
366
.’ We positively affirm that
we hold this faith, that we have always held it, and that we adhere to
it even unto death, condemning all ungodly heresy. We testify, as
before God the Almighty and our Lord Jesus Christ, that we have thought
thus from the heart, and from the soul, ever since we have known
ourselves; and we have the means of showing, and, indeed, of convincing
you, that we have always during the past thus believed and
preached.’
“When this formulary had
been set forth by us, there was no room to gainsay it; but our beloved
emperor himself was the first to testify that it was most orthodox, and
that he coincided in opinion with it; and he exhorted the others to
sign it, and to receive all the doctrine it contained, with the single
addition of the one word—‘consubstantial.’ He
explained that this term implied no bodily condition or change
367
, for that the Son did not derive His
existence from the Father either by means of division or of abscission,
since an immaterial, intellectual, and incorporeal nature could not be
subject to any bodily condition or change
368
. These things must be understood as
bearing a divine and mysterious signification. Thus reasoned our wisest
and most religious emperor. The addition of the word consubstantial has
given occasion for the composition of the following
formulary:—
The Creed published by the Council.
“‘We believe in one
God, Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and invisible. And in
one Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, begotten of the Father;
only-begotten, that is, of the substance of the Father, God of God,
Light of Light, Very God of very God, begotten not made, being of one
substance with the Father: by Whom all things were made both in heaven
and on earth: Who for us men, and for our salvation, came down from
heaven, and was incarnate, and was made man; He suffered, and rose gain
the third day; He ascended into heaven, and is coming to judge both
quick and dead. And we believe in the Holy Ghost. The holy Catholic and
Apostolic Church anathematizes all who say that there was a time when
the Son of God was not; that before He was begotten He was not; that He
was made out of the non-existent; or that He is of a different essence
and of a different substance
369
from the Father;
and that He is susceptible of variation or change.’
“When they had set forth
this formulary, we did not leave without examination that passage in
which it is said that the Son is of the substance of the Father, and
consubstantial with the Father. Questions and arguments thence arose,
and the meaning of the terms was exactly tested. Accordingly they were
led to confess that the word consubstantial signifies that the Son is
of the Father, but not as being a part of the Father. We deemed it
right to receive this opinion; for that is sound doctrine which teaches
that the Son is of the Father, but not part of His substance. From the
love of peace, and lest we should fall from the true belief, we also
accept this view, neither do we reject the term
‘consubstantial.’ For the same reason we admitted the
expression, ‘begotten, but not made;’ for they alleged that
the word ‘made’ applies generally to all things which were
created by the Son, to which the Son is in no respect similar; and that
consequently He is not a created thing, like the things made by Him,
but is of a substance superior to all created objects. The Holy
Scriptures teach Him to be begotten of the Father, by a mode of
generation which is incomprehensible and inexplicable to all created
beings. So also the term ‘of one substance with the
Father,’ when investigated, was accepted not in accordance with
bodily relations or similarity to mortal beings. For it was also shown
that it does not either imply division of substance, nor abscission,
nor any modification or change or diminution in the power of the
Father, all of which are alien from the nature of the unbegotten
Father. It was concluded that the expression ‘
being of one
substance with the Father,
’ implies that the Son of God does
not resemble, in any one respect, the creatures which He has made; but
that to the Father alone, who begat Him, He is in all points perfectly
like: for He is of the essence and of the substance
370
of none save of the Father. This
interpretation having been given of the doctrine, it appeared right to
us to assent to it, especially as we were aware that of the ancients
some learned and celebrated bishops and writers have used the term
‘consubstantial’ with respect to the divinity of the Father
and of the Son.
“These are the
circumstances which I had to communicate respecting the published
formulary of the faith. To it we all agreed, not without investigation,
but, after having subjected the views submitted to us to thorough
examination in the presence of our most beloved emperor, for the above
reasons we all acquiesced in it. We also allowed that the anathema
appended by them to their formulary of faith should be accepted,
because it prohibits the use of words which are not scriptural; through
which almost all the disorder and troubles of the Church have arisen.
And since no passage of the inspired Scripture uses the terms
‘out of the non-existent,’ or that ‘there was a time
when He was not,’ nor indeed any of the other phrases of the same
class, it did not appear reasonable to assert or to teach such things.
In this opinion, therefore, we judged it right to agree; since, indeed,
we had never, at any former period, been accustomed to use such terms
371
. Moreover, the condemnation of the
assertion that before He was begotten He was not, did not appear to
involve any incongruity, because all assent to the fact that He was the
Son of God before He was begotten according to the flesh. And here our
emperor, most beloved by God,
began to reason concerning His
divine origin, and His existence before all ages. He was virtually in
the Father without generation
372
, even before He
was actually begotten, the Father having always been the Father, just
as He has always been a King and a Saviour, and, virtually, all things,
and has never known any change of being or action.
“We have thought it
requisite, beloved brethren, to transmit you an account of these
circumstances, in order to show you what examination and investigation
we bestowed on all the questions which we had to decide; and also to
prove how at one time we resisted firmly, even to the last hour, when
doctrines improperly expressed offended us, and, at another time, we,
without contention, accepted the articles which contained nothing
objectionable, when after a thorough and candid investigation of their
signification, they appeared perfectly conformable with what had been
confessed by us in the formulary of faith which we had
published.”
365
“
πολιτευσάμενον
.” Cf.
Phil. i. 27
, and iii. 20, and
Acts xxiii. 1
366
Matt. xxviii.
19
367
πάθη,
πάθος
368
πάθη,
πάθος
369
ὑποστάσεως
and
οὐσίας
370
ὑποστάσεως
and
οὐσίας
371
The
genuineness of the following sentence is doubted. It is not found in
Socrates or in Epiphanius. But it is not unreasonably held by Valesius
that Socrates, who seems to have undertaken to clear the character of
Eusebius of all heretical taint, purposely suppressed the passage as
inconsistent with orthodoxy. Soc. i. 8. Dr. Newman writes of this
passage, “It is remarkable as shewing his (Constantine’s)
utter ignorance of doctrines which were never intended for discussion
among the unbaptized heathen, or the secularized Christian, that, in
spite of bold avowal of the orthodox faith in detail” (i.e. in
his letter to Arius), “yet shortly after he explained to Eusebius
one of the Nicene declarations in a sense which even Arius would
scarcely have allowed, expressed as it is almost after the manner of
Paulus. “Arians,” 3rd ed., p. 256.
372
Here it has been proposed to read for
ἀγεννήτως
, without generation, which does not admit of an orthodox
interpretation,
ἀειγεννήτως
, i.e. by eternal generation.