maker must explain to us. Whereas we, the people who according to Eunomius are unscientif-
ic in our judgment of objects and in our use of terms, have been taught to call sound (for
instance), not the man from whom strength is absent, but the man from whom disease is
absent; and unmutilated, not the man who keeps away from drinking-parties, but the man
who has no mutilation upon him; and other qualities in the same way we name from the
presence or the absence of something; manly, for instance, and unmanly; sleepy and sleepless;
and all the other terms like that, which custom sanctions.
Still I cannot see what profit there is in deigning to examine such nonsense. For a man
like myself, who has lived to gray hairs1211, and whose eyes are fixed on truth alone, to take
upon his lips the absurd and flippant utterances of a contentious foe, incurs no slight danger
of bringing condemnation on himself. I will therefore pass over both those words and the
adjoining passage; this, for instance, “Truth gives no evidence of any union of natures with
God.” Well, if these words had not been spoken, who ever was there (except yourself) who
mentioned a double nature in the Deity at all? You, however, unite each idea of each name
with the essence of the Father, and deny that anything externally accrues to Him, centering
every one of His names in that essence. Again, “Neither does she write in the statute-book
of our religion any idea that is external and fabricated by ourselves.” With regard to these
words again I shall deprecate the idea that I have quoted them with a view of amusing the
reader with their absurdity; rather I have done so with a view to show with what a slender
equipment of arguments this man, after rating us for our want of system, advances to take
these audacious liberties with the name of Truth. What is he in reasoning, and what is he
in speech, that he should thus revel in showing himself off before his hidebound readers,
who applaud him as victorious over everybody by force of argument when he has brought
312
these disjointed utterances of his dry bombastic jargon to an end1212. “Immortality,” he
says, “is the essence itself.” But what, then, do you assert to be the essence of the Only-be-
gotten? I ask you that: is it immortality, or is it not? For remember that in His essence also
the singleness admits, as you say, of no complexity of nature. If, then Eunomius denies that
immortality is the essence of the Son, it is clear what he is aiming at; for it does not require
an exceedingly penetrating understanding to discover what is the direct opposite to the
immortal. Just as the logic of dichotomy exhibits the destructible instead of the indestructible,
and the mutable instead of the immutable, so it exhibits the mortal instead of the immortal.
1211 This cannot have been written earlier than 384. The preceding twelve books, of which an instalment
only was read to Gregory the Nazianzene and others during the Council of Constantinople, 381, must have oc-
cupied him a considerable time: and there may have been an interval after that before this essay was composed.
1212 τὰς στομφώδεις…ξηροστομίας κακοσυνθέτως διαπεραίνοντα. The editt. have διαπεραίνοντες, which
Gulonius’ Latin follows, “arrogantes has sicci oris voces malâ compositione trajicientes,” i.e. his hearers get
through them with bad pronunciation.
582
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.