34. Augustin said: Why our Lord said: "I have power to lay down my soul and power
to take it," is known to all; because He was about to suffer and to rise again. But I ask of you
again and again, If God could in no way suffer injury, why did he send souls hither?
Fortunatus said: To impose a limit on contrary nature.
35. Augustin said: And did God omnipotent, merciful and supreme, that He might
impose a restraint on contrary nature, wish it to be limited so that He might make us unres-
trained?
Fortunatus said: But so He calls us back to Himself.
36. Augustin said: If He recalls to Himself from an unrestrained state, if from sin, from
error, from misery, what need was there for the soul to suffer so great evils through so long
a time till the world ends? since God by whom you say it was sent could in no way suffer
injury.
Fortunatus said: What then am I to say?
124
37. Augustin said: I know that you have nothing to say, and that I, when I was among
you, never found anything to say on this question, and that I was thus admonished from
on high to leave that error and to be converted to the Catholic faith or rather to recall it, by
the indulgence of Him who did not permit me to inhere forever in this fallacy. But if you
confess that you have nothing to reply, I will expound the Catholic faith to all those hearing
and investigating, seeing that they are believers, if they permit and wish.
Fortunatus said: Without prejudice to my profession I might say: when I shall have
reconsidered with my superiors the things that have been opposed by you, if they fail to re-
spond to this question of mine, which is now in like manner proposed to me by you, it will
be in my contemplation (since I desire my soul to be liberated by an assured faith) to come
to the investigation of this thing that you have proposed to me and that you promise you
will show.
Augustin said: Thanks be to God.
206
Disputation of the Second Day.