all such terms as these are strictly applicable only to that Nature which passes all understand-
ing, whereas “generated” exhibits community of name with even the inferior forms of the
lower creation. For we call a dog, and a frog, and all things that come into the world by way
of generation, “generated.” And moreover, the term “ungenerate” is not only employed of
that which exists without a cause, but has also a proper application to that which is nonex-
istent. The Scindapsus835 is called ungenerate, the Blityri836 is ungenerate, the Minotaur is
ungenerate, the Cyclops, Scylla, the Chimæra are ungenerate, not in the sense of existing
without generation, but in the sense of never having come into being at all. If, then, the
names more peculiarly Divine are common to the Son with the Father, and if it is the others,
those which are equivocally employed either of the non-existent or of the lower animals—if
it is these, I say, which are divergent, let his “generate and ungenerate” be so: Eunomius’
powerful argument against us itself upholds the cause of truth in testifying that there is no
divergence in respect of nature, because no divergence can be perceived in the names837.
But if he asserts the difference of essence to exist between the “generate” and the “ungenerate,”
as it does between fire and water, and is of opinion that the names, like those which he has
mentioned in his examples, are in the same mutual relation as “fire” and “water,” the horrid
character of his blasphemy will here again be brought to light, even if we hold our peace.
197
For fire and water have a nature mutually destructive, and each is destroyed, if it comes to
be in the other, by the prevalence of the more powerful element. If, then, he lays down the
doctrine that the Nature of the Ungenerate differs thus from that of the Only-begotten, it
is surely clear that he logically makes this destructive opposition to be involved in the diver-
gence of their essences, so that their nature will be, by this reasoning, incompatible and in-
communicable, and the one would be consumed by the other, if both should be found to
be mutually inclusive or co-existent.
How then is the Son “in the Father” without being destroyed, and how does the Father,
coming to be “in the Son,” remain continually unconsumed, if, as Eunomius says, the special
attribute of fire, as compared with water, is maintained in the relation of the Generate to
the Ungenerate? Nor does their definition regard communion as existing between earth
and air, for the former is stable, solid, resistent, of downward tendency and heavy, while air
has a nature made up of the contrary attributes. So white and black are found in opposition
among colours, and men are agreed that the circle is not the same with the triangle, for each,
according to the definition of its figure, is precisely that which the other is not. But I am
835 These are names applied to denote existences purely imaginary; the other names belong to classical
mythology.
836 These are names applied to denote existences purely imaginary; the other names belong to classical
mythology.
837 That is, in the names more peculiarly appropriate to the Divine Nature.
377
Thereafter he discusses the divergence of names and of things, speaking,…