Letter LXXXIX.
(a.d. 406.)
To Festus, My Lord Well Beloved, My Son Honourable and Worthy of Esteem, Augustin
Sends Greeting in the Lord.
1. If, on behalf of error and inexcusable dissension, and falsehoods which have been in
every way possible disproved, men are so presumptuous as to persevere in boldly assailing
and threatening the Catholic Church, which seeks their salvation, how much more is it
reasonable and right for those who maintain the truth of Christian peace and unity,—truth
which commends itself even to those who profess to deny it or attempt to resist it,—to labour
constantly and with energy, not only in the defence of those who are already Catholics, but
374
also for the correction of those who are not yet within the Church! For if obstinacy aims at
the possession and exercise of indomitable strength, how great should be the strength of
constancy which devotes persevering and unwearied labours to a cause which it knows to
be both pleasing to God, and beyond all question necessarily approved by the judgment of
wise men!
2. Could there, moreover, be anything more lamentable as an instance of perversity,
than for men not only to refuse to be humbled by the correction of their wickedness, but
even to claim commendation for their conduct, as is done by the Donatists, when they boast
that they are the victims of persecution; either through incredible blindness not knowing,
or through inexcusable passion pretending not to know, that men are made martyrs not by
the amount of their suffering, but by the cause in which they suffer? This I would say even
were I opposing men who were only involved in the darkness of error, and suffering penalties
on that account most truly merited, and who had not dared to assault any one with insane
violence. But what shall I say against those whose fatal obstinacy is such that it is checked
only by fear of losses, and is taught only by exile how universal (as had been foretold) is the
diffusion of the Church, which they prefer to attack rather then to acknowledge? And if the
things which they suffer under this most gentle discipline be compared with those things
which they in reckless fury perpetrate, who does not see to which party the name of perse-
cutors more truly belongs? Nay, even though wicked sons abstain from violence, they do,
by their abandoned way of life, inflict upon their affectionate parents a much more serious
wrong than their father and mother inflict upon them, when, with a sternness proportioned
to the strength of their love, they endeavour without dissimulation to compel them to live
uprightly.
3. There exist the strongest evidences in public documents, which you can read if you
please, or rather, which I beseech and exhort you to read, by which it is proved that their
predecessors, who originally separated themselves from the peace of the Church, did of their
own accord dare to bring accusation against Cæcilianus before the Emperor by means of
Anulinus, who was proconsul at that time. Had they gained the day in that trial, what else
To Festus
830
To Festus