9. He speaks as follows:1087 “And there is a certain Marcion1088 of Pontus,1089 who is
185
even now still teaching his followers to think that there is some other God greater than the
tinguishes them has no significance. Although, therefore, it cannot be determined whether Justin wrote two
separate works against heretics, it is quite probable that he did not. The conduct of Eusebius in this connection
is very peculiar. After mentioning the work against Marcion, he at once gives a quotation in such a way as to
convey the impression that the quotation is taken from this work, but it is really taken from the first Apology.
This makes it very probable that he had not seen this work against Marcion, a conclusion which is confirmed
by its omission from the list of Justin’s writings given in chap. 18. It is claimed by many that Eusebius practices
a little deception here, wishing to convey the impression that he knew a book which he did not know. This is
not in accord with his usual conduct (as he seldom hesitates to confess his ignorance of any matter), and his
general character for candor and honesty must be taken into account in deciding the case. He does not state
directly that the quotation is taken from the work against Marcion, and it is possible that the seeming reference
of it to that source was an oversight on his part. But it must be acknowledged, if that be the case, that he was
very careless in making the quotation.
1087 Justin, Apol. I. 26.
1088 Marcion cannot be called a Gnostic in the strict sense of the term. He was rather an anti-Jewish reformer.
He had much in common with the Gnostics, but laid stress upon belief rather than upon knowledge. He developed
no complete system as did the extreme and perverted Paulinism, considering Paul the only true apostle and re-
jecting the others as Judaizing teachers. He cut the Gospel away from its historical connections, repudiating the
Old Testament and all of the New except a mutilated Gospel of Luke and the Epistles of Paul, and denying the
identity of the God of the Old Testament with the Supreme God, and the identity of Jesus with the promised
Jewish Messiah. He magnified the mercy of God in redemption at the expense of creation, which he attributed
to the demiurge, and in which he saw nothing good. He was an extreme anti-metaphysician, and the first Biblical
critic. He was born in Pontus, was the son of a bishop, went to Rome about 135 a.d., and endeavored to carry
out his reforms there, but was unsuccessful, and very soon broke with the Church. He traveled extensively and
disseminated his doctrines very widely. The sect existed well on into the Middle Ages, and some of his opinions
have never been completely eradicated. In Rome the Gnostic Cerdon exercised great influence over him, and
to him are doubtless due many of Marcion’s Gnostic traits. The dualism which he held in common with the
Gnostics arose rather from practical than speculative considerations; but his followers in the fourth and fifth
centuries, when they had lost his practical religious spirit and yet retained his dualism, passed over quite naturally
into Manicheeism. He was attacked by Justin, Irenæus, Tertullian, and all the anti-heretical writers of the early
Church, and was considered one of the most dangerous of heretics. A complete monograph upon Marcion is
still a desideratum, but he is discussed in all the general accounts of Gnosticism; see especially the brief but ex-
cellent account by Harnack, Dogmengeschichte, I. 197–214.
1089 Pontus was a province in Northeastern Asia Minor, bordering upon the Black Sea.
409
The Heresiarchs of that Age.