ever done this. But apart from this, when your predecessors brought before the Emperor
Constantine, by means of the proconsul Anulinus, their accusations against Cæcilianus,
who was then bishop of Carthage, with whom as a guilty person they refused to have com-
munion, they were not endeavouring to recover something of their own which they had
lost, but were by calumnies assailing one who was, as we think, and as the issue of the judicial
proceedings showed, an innocent man; and what more heinous crime could have been
perpetrated by them than this? If, however, as you erroneously suppose, they did in his case
deliver up to the judgment of the civil powers a man who was indeed guilty, why do you
object to our doing that which your own party first presumed to do, and for doing which
we would not find fault with them, if they had done it not with an envious desire to do harm,
but with the intention of reproving and correcting what was wrong. But we have no hesitation
in finding fault with you, who think that we are criminal in bringing any complaint before
a Christian emperor against the enemies of our communion, seeing that a document given
by your predecessors to Anulinus the proconsul, to be forwarded by him to the Emperor
Constantine, bore this superscription: “Libellus Ecclesiæ Catholicæ, criminum Cæciliani,
traditus a parte Majorini.”2170 We find fault, moreover, with them more particularly, because
when they had of their own accord gone to the Emperor with accusations against Cæcilianus,
which they ought by all means to have in the first place proved before those who were his
colleagues beyond the sea, and when the Emperor, acting in a much more orderly way than
they had done, referred to bishops the decision of this case pertaining to bishops which had
been brought before him, they, even when defeated by a decision against them, would not
come to peace with their brethren. Instead of this, they next accused at the bar of the tem-
poral sovereign, not Cæcilianus only, but also the bishops who had been appointed judges;
and finally, from a second episcopal tribunal they appealed to the Emperor again. Nor did
they consider it their duty to yield either to truth or to peace when he himself inquired into
the case and gave his decision.
387
14. Now what else could Constantine have decreed against Cæcilianus and his friends,
if they had been defeated when your predecessors accused them, than the things decreed
against the very men who, having of their own accord brought the accusations, and having
failed to prove what they alleged, refused even when defeated to acquiesce in the truth? The
Emperor, as you know, in that case decreed for the first time that the property of those who
were convicted of schism and obstinately resisted the unity of the Church should be confis-
cated. If, however, the issue had been that your predecessors who brought the accusations
had gained their case, and the Emperor had made some such decree against the communion
to which Cæcilianus belonged, you would have wished the emperors to be called the friends
of the Church’s interests, and the guardians of her peace and unity. But when such things
2170 See Letter LXXXVIII. § 2.
854
To Vincentius